TN: Camille's (Mar 16, 2024)

Jeff Grossman

Jeff Grossman
attendees: Camille+Ben, Bruce+Tammy, Dan, Jeff

Friends are cooking at their friends' house and I am invited. Of course, I was told there was no need to bring anything so I made a batch of pistachio gelato and grabbed a few bottles.

The friends' house had been renovated many years ago by a married couple, both of whom are chefs, so half the ground floor is the kitchen (the other half is seating). This kitchen is fabulously equipped and every inch of it is packed with dishes, pots and pans, serving ware, a vertical herb garden, and plenty of comestibles. I marvel at all this because my kitchen is the size of a postage stamp.

After much back and forth, the cooks decided on this menu:

Amuse: sauteed razor clam in lemon-butter
First: garganelli with sun-dried tomato pesto and fresh basil
Main: fricasseed chicken with leeks and mushrooms (could it be any more wine-friendly?)
Salad: simple green salad with slices of Beaufort and Tomme de Savoie
Dessert: tarte aux fraises and pistachio gelato


The hostess, Camille, favors les vins vivants, which corresponds roughly to natural wines. She has textbooks on the subject and has a good number of bottles in the house. She likes the vividness of the wines, the fragrances and flavors that pop. Interestingly, she does not like pet nat.

I harbor my prejudices about natural wines and mousiness and the bacteriological problems that beset the absolutely-no-sulfur makers, but I'm willing to try. ((And maybe I'm misunderstanding her?: If Les Vins Vivants means the school of Lapierre, then I'm all in.))

Here we go:

La Stoppa 2013 IGT Emilia "Ageno" - The 'welcome' cup. Tastes like I remember it: citric, tannic, a bit of rose water and pine oil, incredibly present, really good but an acquired taste; later in the evening, the wine's grip relaxes a little and it is more pleasant

Jean Vesselle NV Champagne Brut Rose "Oeil de Perdrix" - disg. 1/19/22, 100% pinot noir, big wine and fruit-forward, roses and strawberries, the minerality arrives during the finish, more rocks than chalk, works well at the table

Ferme de L'Yonnière (Jérome Forget) 2019 Poire "Champs de Poirier" - like my previous bottle, lots of stuff floating around in it but never mind: it's sweet and just a tad funky, somewhat heavy texture for a cider but a great bottle, sufficiently natural for Camille (yay)

Brocard, Jean-Marc 2022 Chablis VV "Sainte-Claire" - the nose screams Chablis but the mouth is kinda soft; after a half-hour, the palate comes to life, too, and this is a pretty nice bottle of Chablis, not as incisive as wine from better dirt but rings that Chablis bell and the persistence is decent

Dom. G. Lignier 2016 Morey-Saint-Dénis - a little pine-y when opened but that soon goes away; this is a beautiful Village wine with red fruits, balanced acids, moss or maybe dark greens, terrific

Dom. Brand et Fils (Philippe Brand) 2022 Vin d'Alsace "La Table des Rois" - 13.5%, 2 g/l rs, 100% pinot noir, whole cluster, 8 months in old barrels, no additions / sulfur / fining / filtering; vivid wine, aromatic (and a little rustic), black currants and cherries and forest-y smells, a little nutmeg maybe, excellent natural wine

Lame Delisle Boucard (Dom. des Chesnaies) 2011 Bourgueil "Cuvee Prestige" - from three steep hillside parcels (Beauvais, Brunetières, Bézards), medium weight, smooth tannins, Loire franc that shows a little citrus and well-behaved pyrazines, long finish, wow bottle

After dinner we went to a farewell party being thrown for yet another set of friends at the house of yet another set of friends. Bumped into fellow disorderly, Scott Reiner there, which was a pleasant surprise.

All the way around, a fun evening.
 
was this in boston?

i've not had their oeil de perdrix unfortunately, but given the others i am a little surprised by the "big" descriptor, yet everything else fits my expectations

have not had prestige as old as 2011, sounds fabulous. had a lovely '76 (another cuvee, so source of vineyards unknown) a few years ago, and the bottlings that are meant to age faster than prestige from recent vintages are doing so with aplomb
 
Brooklyn.

It was less 'big' once it settled down but there was a rush when first poured.

It was very good and it's reasonably priced, too.
 
the 2022 brocard ste claire has yet to hit my market, but the 2021 is a real humdinger for village chablis. 2021 is simply a great chablis vintage (sadly a rare thing these days.)
 
originally posted by robert ames:
the 2022 brocard ste claire has yet to hit my market, but the 2021 is a real humdinger for village chablis. 2021 is simply a great chablis vintage (sadly a rare thing these days.)
And in my market, the ‘22 is sold out.
I wonder what 2023 was like in Chablis? Anticipated arrival here (FL) at the end of April.
 
originally posted by Florida Jim:

I wonder what 2023 was like in Chablis?

Lyle put out an offer for 2023 Dampt and the Dampt winemaker notes described the vintage as lighter and fresher than 2022, but still plenty of sun and a 'classic vintage inside the range of warm vintages'. I guess there's no going back in time! He compared it to 2012 in Chablis.
 
Rahsaan,
I appreciate the input
While Robert seems to really like 2021 I have had mixed quality in wines below grand cru. Whereas, 2022 has been pretty good so far (below grand cru). But Jeff’s comment about a certain softness when first opened rings true. FWIW, I got that same impression when initially tasting several 2019’s - most of those wines have become impressive - so I hold out hope for the ‘22’s.
“Classic vintage inside the range of warm vintages” makes me think to go with trusted producers only until sampling is more complete. But, again, I thank you for the input - there isn’t much written about ‘23 yet.
 
I'm fond of 2012 Chablis. It's not 2010 or 14, but it's far from a solar vintage. I've opened several in the past year or so.
 
originally posted by Florida Jim:
Rahsaan,

“Classic vintage inside the range of warm vintages” makes me think to go with trusted producers only until sampling is more complete.

Sounds wise. It was apparently a rainy season, so lots of things can go wrong. (Even if there are always great wines from some people)
 
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:

Brocard, Jean-Marc 2022 Chablis VV "Sainte-Claire" - the nose screams Chablis but the mouth is kinda soft; after a half-hour, the palate comes to life, too, and this is a pretty nice bottle of Chablis, not as incisive as wine from better dirt but rings that Chablis bell and the persistence is decent

Just had the ‘23 BTG while dining at RPM Seafood in Chicago after a day spent at Abbott. My impression comports with your note. It was correct and clearly Chablis, perhaps a tad less zippy than my Platonic ideal, but maybe that’s the vintage speaking (or possibly an unfortunate comparison with the earlier glass of Vilmart Grand Cellier, which was its usual fine self).

Mark Lipton
 
Back
Top