Honest, Abe?

Thor

Thor Iverson
Rijckaert 2006 Bourgogne Blanc (Burgundy) An austere skeleton of a wine, clean, direct, and stark. Nice enough, but it sacrifices any hint of complexity for directness. (12/08)

Lini 910 Labrusca Lambrusco Bianco (Emilia-Romagna) Fragrant. Green apples, acidity, and fun lightness. My first white Lambrusco; I didnt even know they existed until I saw this bottle. (12/08)

Pepe 2001 Trebbiano dAbruzzo (Abruzzi) Smells, unmistakably, of kriek lambic, with all the sourness and brett that impliesand not some easy-drinking Lindemans bottling either, but an extreme, take-no-prisoners Cantillon version. The texture is of drying soup, with fantastic minerality enveloped in lanolin. Very complex and strikingly long, with fine balance. Not that this is any surprise, but the wine is very divisive; among a half-dozen tasters of this bottle, about as many despise it as adore it. (12/08)

i Clivi di Ferdinando Zanusso 1997 Galea Corno di Rosazzo (Colli Orientali del Friuli) Fairly advanced for this bottling, which has spent some time in a warmish store (Vintages, Belmont Center) and might have been displayed standing up for a time. All this really means, though, is that the wine is a lot closer to full maturity than pristine bottles: honeysuckle and fine-grained pollen with a lovely milky texture and very good length. (12/08)

Blanchard Vin de Table de France Lot 1 (Loire) A mysterious wine. A bit of online research leads to the following: sauvignon blanc and, believe it or not, cabernet (franc or sauvignon, we dont know) vinified white. The thought behind the closure is equally mysterious: a crown cap under a wax capsule. Kind of irritating. OK, so how about the wine? Bewildering is what it is: foamy, powdery, and sweet, with a bit of lime. Very, very strange. (12/08)

Rauen 2004 Detzemer Maximiner Klosterlay Riesling Auslese Trocken 7 05 (Mosel-Saar-Ruwer) Makrut lime, fresh coconut, and papaya. Bright and sunlit, and while the wine is good in a tropical sort of way while it lasts, the finish is disappointingly short. (12/08)

Scholium Project 2007 Eurydice Rocky Hill (California) Pinot gris, according to the web site. Ill take their word for it. All I can get out of this wine is wax and fatand not the fat that critics use to suggest a lack of balancing acidity. No, I mean actual fat. Stale fat, too. But mostly, it smells and tastes of wax. Are they kidding? (12/08)

Scholium Project 2006 The Prince in His Caves Farina (California) Sauvignon blanc, and for a change with this producer the cpage is actually reflected in the wine, which smells of sweat and asparagus, tastes like green pepper, and is dominated by a fierce, off-putting acidity. (12/08)

Scholium Project 2007 Naucratis Lost Slough (California) Verdelho. Given a sufficiently open mind, this actually seems like it might be wine: sweet mango and persimmon, albeit with the texture of a smoothie. Drinkable, but you wont want much of it. (12/08)

Lurton Chteau La Louvire 1979 Graves Blanc (Bordeaux) Young-tasting, believe it or not. Lime with hints of Sprite the wines a bit slurpy but this eventually resolves to tonic and sorbet. Filaments of metal drift through the finish. Precise. Very good, but almost excellent. (12/08)

Dillon Les Plantiers du Haut-Brion 1974 Graves Blanc (Bordeaux) Molten aluminum, creamy, and very long. A touch of brown sugar hints at the age, but this has held up extremely well. Very, very good wine, but drink up. (12/08)

Gros Domaine de Montbourgeau 2000 ltoile Cuve Spciale (Jura) Racy minerality in a wind tunnel. If there was such a thing as chalkfruit, this would have it. Intense and pear-textured (but not -flavored), with a tartness that really emerges as the wine airs. Extremely good. (12/08)

CH Berres 2001 rziger Wrzgarten Riesling Auslese 12 02 (Mosel-Saar-Ruwer) Raw iron and light petroleum, perhaps some aluminum. Shockingly primary (almost raw, actually); this not only is far from maturity, its not even close to closing up yet. (12/08)
 
Pepe 2001 Trebbiano dAbruzzo (Abruzzi) ...the wine is very divisive; among a half-dozen tasters of this bottle, about as many despise it as adore it. (12/08)

People seldom like what they cannot understand...
 
This will all be explained in my upcoming companion volume Shards, Filaments, & the Metals That Love Them, out soon from Harper-Collins.
 
originally posted by Thor:

Scholium Project 2007 Eurydice Rocky Hill (California) Pinot gris, according to the web site. Ill take their word for it. All I can get out of this wine is wax and fatand not the fat that critics use to suggest a lack of balancing acidity. No, I mean actual fat. Stale fat, too. But mostly, it smells and tastes of wax. Are they kidding? (12/08)

Scholium Project 2006 The Prince in His Caves Farina (California) Sauvignon blanc, and for a change with this producer the cpage is actually reflected in the wine, which smells of sweat and asparagus, tastes like green pepper, and is dominated by a fierce, off-putting acidity. (12/08)

Scholium Project 2007 Naucratis Lost Slough (California) Verdelho. Given a sufficiently open mind, this actually seems like it might be wine: sweet mango and persimmon, albeit with the texture of a smoothie. Drinkable, but you wont want much of it. (12/08)

BUTT!!!!!!

Mark Lipton
 
So to sum up, "SCHOLIUM ROOLZ!!"

Stale fat.

Sweat and asparagus.

Perhaps it was the venue?

...insert internet winkie here...
 
originally posted by Thor:
Honest, Abe?Lini 910 Labrusca Lambrusco Bianco (Emilia-Romagna) Fragrant. Green apples, acidity, and fun lightness. My first white Lambrusco; I didnt even know they existed until I saw this bottle. (12/08)

Pepe 2001 Trebbiano dAbruzzo (Abruzzi) Smells, unmistakably, of kriek lambic, with all the sourness and brett that impliesand not some easy-drinking Lindemans bottling either, but an extreme, take-no-prisoners Cantillon version. The texture is of drying soup, with fantastic minerality enveloped in lanolin. Very complex and strikingly long, with fine balance. Not that this is any surprise, but the wine is very divisive; among a half-dozen tasters of this bottle, about as many despise it as adore it. (12/08)

Interesting. Never heard of a white Lambrusco either. I would certainly try one if I saw it.

I had a similar experience with the Pepe. Not for everyone, but I loved it. What temp did you serve it at? I find these show better a bit warmer than cellar temps.
 
Thanks, fun read as always, Thor.

I'm bringing the 2000 Domaine de Montbourgeau ltoile Cuve Spciale to Joe's Vin Jaune shindig tonight. I'm really interested to see if I am transported to a wind tunnel--my expectations are now ridiculously high. Suggest I open this for a while before hitting the road?

Interesting note on the i Clivi, as well. I tasted, liked and bought some of the '99 at the Vintages Belmont store grand opening, when the importer was pouring it. I think she pulled it right from her stash, so hoping it is not so advanced.

-Michael
 
I'm really interested to see if I am transported to a wind tunnel

Bring a comb if so.

Suggest I open this for a while before hitting the road?

Not to encourage a felony, but it might not hurt.

I think she pulled it right from her stash, so hoping it is not so advanced.

I own some '99 as well. I'm a little dismayed at the conditions in that store, given the rather elevated markups on everything, but the selection is certainly impressive.
 
originally posted by Thor:
I'm a little dismayed at the conditions in that store, given the rather elevated markups on everything, but the selection is certainly impressive.
I used to ask to have select bottles pulled from the basement. It was pretty cool down there even in mid-summer. The downside was that only Eric seemed to know what was down there and how to find it so if he wasn't in I usually just bought off the display.
 
originally posted by Thor:
Note that I'm talking about Belmont, not West Concord. I don't want to conflate the stores.

Thank you. Those of us outside 128 appreciate the segregation. It makes us feel better. Seriously.
 
A '95 Pepe last year was an extraordinary wine.

The descriptions of the Scholium whites do not inspire confidence, but I do have a bottle of the '07 SB that I'm looking forward to trying. I also have a few of the Pets, which might be more promising. In my youth, I actually believed that I would "try anything once". Now I know that is not true, but I am willing to try these wines.

Anyhow, thank you for the warning.
 
Thank you. Those of us outside 128 appreciate the segregation. It makes us feel better. Seriously.

The internet has killed sarcasm. Resuscitated it. And then killed it again.

is the cuvee speciale 100% chard, or some savagnin in the mix too?

The web site says a tiny little bit of savagnin, mostly chardonnay.

I am willing to try these wines.

I was, after this one:

Scholium Project 2006 Heliopolis Delu (Suisun Valley) Utterly fascinating. Its got the blast door-crashing-down weight of some of the nuttier Friulian wines (which I like), a cyclone of minerality and dried-past-individuality fruit, and a long, claypot finish. I wouldnt want to drink a whole bottle of it, because its just too much, but its really compelling in smaller quantities. (5/08)

...but now I think my interest in further exploration is pretty much over.
 
Back
Top