WTN: February ousted

MarkS

Mark Svereika
Before I realized it, February left me, and I, it. There's a reason this month is so short, despite being very presidential.

BioVio, Riviera Ligure di Ponente, Vermentino di Albenga, 2008
I believe this might have been my first 2008 wine. Color is a pretty greenish-grey light gold with a tingly herbal nose. Lots of Mennen aftershave fills the palate, with herbally ripe fruit. A bit pinot grigio-like, finishes soft. 13% B/B+

Tempier, Bandol, 1998
Bright cherry red colored. A muted nose, not sure from still being asleep or dumbstruck at being opened in the dead of winter. You can still make out the sweatsox and unopened, nighttime flowers. With air (lots of it, as in 'the next day'), this opens up to be an elegant mourvedre, despite having very tough nail-like tannins. There's tar, vine twig, campfire smoke, but also some cooked fruit compote as well. This is one wine that drinks better the second day than the first. B+

St. Cosme, Cote Rotie, 1998
Thankfully, my last and final bottle. But I repeat myself. Never wasting my money on this crap again, no matter how cheap it is, and it isn't.

Vincent Dauvissat, Chablis, 'les Sechet', 2002
Ahh...finally: real. good. wine. Salty lemon drop bonbons on the bright nose. Beautifully rendered chardonnay with salty-mineral infused lemon rind with the lightish touch of oaken vanilla. With further airing, the oaken notes fade and are replaced by talcum powder and candlewax. Slightly short finish, but I'm not complaining. This is a delicate wash of a wine, like dipping your hands in a bowl of cool lemon-water on a warm summer's day. Lovely. A-/B+

Domaine Bru-Bache, Jurancon, 'lEminende', 2001
Medium gold color with an almost green Chartreuse cast. Spring flowers and wood ear fungus on the nose. Sweet-sour dimension to the palate creating a nice interplay of flavors among the notes of kumquat and quince, and a finish of freshly burnt sugar with lemongrass, slight bitter note on the end. Interesting melange of flavors and not heavy, despite being 14% alcohol. The Mansengs can invite me to dinner anytime! A-
 
originally posted by MarkS: WTN: February oustedSt. Cosme, Cote Rotie, 1998

Mark, Yours is the first unfavorable review I've seen of this bottling. Just not your style? Or what?

. . . . . Pete
 
originally posted by Peter Creasey:
originally posted by MarkS: WTN: February oustedSt. Cosme, Cote Rotie, 1998

Mark, Yours is the first unfavorable review I've seen of this bottling. Just not your style? Or what?

. . . . . Pete

Pete, most definately not my style, but let me give you some context. 3 bottles of the 1998: all brooding masses of unelegant syrah, and wood. 3 bottles of their 2001, all having 'problems', mostly volatile acidity, that I couldn't even finish an opened bottle. So, yeah, I don't like these wines and ever so glad they are out of my cellar. Like a reeking corpse, you want all evidence removed. My Cote Rotie $'s will go to those producers whose wines I've liked over the years, like Jasmin, Gallet, Burgaud, etc.
 
originally posted by Peter Creasey:
originally posted by MarkS: WTN: February oustedSt. Cosme, Cote Rotie, 1998

Mark, Yours is the first unfavorable review I've seen of this bottling. Just not your style? Or what?

. . . . . Pete

I'll give you another negative review. Barruol likes new oak far more than I do.
 
originally posted by MarkS: 3 bottles of the 1998: all brooding masses of unelegant syrah, and wood. 3 bottles of their 2001, all having 'problems', mostly volatile acidity, that I couldn't even finish an opened bottle.

Mark, Thanks, I am now persuaded.

Interesting that there seem to quite a few people (obviously elsewhere) who give this wine high ratings. Perhaps these folks are just suffering from the "sheep" mentality.

. . . . . Pete
 
originally posted by Peter Creasey:
Interesting that there seem to quite a few people (obviously elsewhere) who give this wine high ratings. Perhaps these folks are just suffering from the "sheep" mentality.
Maybe they drink important barbera?
 
Back
Top