TN: Syrah trio, Szechuan Cidre, Oregon Calva, crabby Auslese,

Christian Miller (CMM)

Christian Miller
Crozes-Hermitage la Matiniere 2007, Ferraton - gamey raw young Syrah aroma with green peppercorn, a bit of truffle; medium body, ok acid, slightly green boiled young dark berry fruit with a distinct salumi tone, perhaps mercaptans although a charming version if so; medium long, moderate but dry tannins. Rather lean, quite Northern Rhoney. ***(*?)

Syrah Monterey Arroyo Secco 2007, Ventana - nice deep purple; fine pure Syrah nose with young grapy-blackberry fruit and a distinct green peppercorn note; medium body, some density, pure Syrah fruit with cool peppery character, nice balancing acidity and tannins, medium length with hint of bitterness. Not complex but good balanced cool climate Syrah. Develops a nice savory tone with 2 days air. ***(*?)

Syrah Cotes-du-Rhone 2009, St. Cosme - dark purply color; moderate aroma of ripe young plum-blackberry fruit with suggestions of tarragon or anise; medium body, lively acid, plump ripe Rhoney fruit, moderate but dry tannins, with an earthy-clay tone on the finish. Very much a southern Rhone wine, despite being 100% Syrah. ***

A nice showing for the modestly price ($14?) Ventana, not at all the odd man out in this trio.

Cidre Pays d'Auge NV, Domaine du Manoir de Montreuil (Michel Giard) - aggressive if fairly fine mousse, forced the cork out as soon as the basket was off, holds a head briefly; nice yeasty appley aroma; medium body, still fruity, demi-sec style, finishes with barely bitter apple skin flavor. The right stuff, tasty with quinoa and sweet potato "risotto", pork loin rolled in szechuan pepper and cardamom, sauteed apples. ***+

Oregon Apple "Eaux de Vie" aged in oak NV, Clearwater Creek - pale gold color; pure appley fruit and alcohol with mild woody tone in nose; lively appley fruit with a touch of butterscotch, punctuated with alcoholic heat that builds in finish. Despite 8 years in Limousin oak, this is fairly raw stuff, although pure and focused. ***

Dungeness Crab season out here...that means Riesling.

Riesling Wehlener Sonnenuhr Auslese 2005, JJ Prum - just emerging from its shell, a touch of SO2, but mostly vibrant minerally fresh Mosellish Riesling, long and (for an Auslese) quite lean and lively. ****

Riesling Bernkasteler Lay Auslese 2003, Dr. Thanisch - brassy-gold; moderate nose with ripe apricotty-honeyed fruit; medium body, plump with low acid, simple but tasty sweet apricotty Riesling fruit with a touch of jasmine; medium length. All the issues of 2003 are plain to see, but this was a jolly quaff with wokked crab with ginger & spring Onion. ***/****
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:
It just turned 6 years old, maybe that helped. Plus he had the Auslese.
Seems closer to five years than six. Remember Southern Hemisphere wines celebrate birthdays earlier in the year than Northern.
 
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):

And yet, strangely, I enjoyed it. What's wrong with me?

Maybe you've just been analyzing too many organic wines lately...

-Eden (liking the Ventana wines I've tasted recently- good exposition of terroir and varietal typicity, and natural matches with food and diminishing financial resources)
 
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
Are you allowed to drink Prum WS SL at age 5? I thought there were laws about that sort of thing.
I think as everywhere, there's been a progression so that wines can be drunk earlier than in the past. I have been served many a 5-10 year-old wine from all possible Prädikats and vineyards when visiting J-J Prüm and been amazed at how delicious they are, even though there is plenty more development ahead and without the slightest diminishment in quality from the historic level.
 
originally posted by Eden Mylunsch:
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):

And yet, strangely, I enjoyed it. What's wrong with me?

Maybe you've just been analyzing too many organic wines lately...

-Eden (liking the Ventana wines I've tasted recently- good exposition of terroir and varietal typicity, and natural matches with food and diminishing financial resources)
Hilariously random quote from a fairly long discussion. Useful too; it could be interpreted a number of ways.
 
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
originally posted by Rahsaan:
It just turned 6 years old, maybe that helped. Plus he had the Auslese.

That just makes it worse!

Not in my experience. Auslesen take longer to close down (if they do, cf. Claude) than the lower pradikat wines, so 5/6 years is still okay. The auction (i.e. botrytis-driven and/or eiswein-fortified) Auslesen behave differently as well - they seem to shut down harder and earlier. I've not had an Eiswein that was past its closed stage without being over-mature (for my taste), so don't know about those, although if you pick out certain auction Auslesen from famous Eiswein vintages some of the wines seem to be cracking up. Great vinegar, though.
 
Back
Top