1993 Pierre Overnoy Arbois Pupillin 12.5%

Oswaldo Costa

Oswaldo Costa
Last November, Thierry Puzelat told a little birdie that he thought Poulsard could outlast Pinot Noir, and offered as proof that he had recently gone to a vertical in honor of Pierre Overnoy’s 80th birthday in which they tasted 13 vintages from the last 50 years, all of which were in fine fettle. When I noticed that our copain Matteo Mollo had some fairly priced 93s at Wine Bottega, I sounded him out, got encouraging reports, and dipped. Light tawny, the color of pale tea. After the initial bottleneck mustiness dissipates, the aromas are faint, an indeterminate mix of red berries, muskiness, and that pungent scent found in hairdressing salons, ugliness required to generate beauty (hydrogen peroxide?). The mouth feel, on the other organ, is quite lovely, with fresh acidity and lively fruit, a happy couple living in harmony after working out their kinks, not their kinkiness. To the end, this showed the charming and graceful dignity of an avian ossature softly burdened, like an ageing Fred Astaire. I don’t know about longevity, but who knows how this was stored before it got to Matteo, whereas Puzelat tasted bottles that had never seen the world.
 
Cool Oswaldo! I am glad you got to try it finally! As i noted, i put that wine in a lineup of some of the "best and brightest" (including other overnoy's) at a relatively recent Jura fete. Many people spotted this 93 as the best on the table, whatever that means. For transparency sake the wines were all bought buy us through LDM and they seemingly have been stored somewhere in Joe's attic (just kidding). I really like the wine and look forward to trying a couple more bottles that i bought for myself down the line. BTW, did you end up decanting or how was the estimation of breathing time for you?
 
I opened the bottle three hours before drinking, but did nothing else (other than periodically checking the bottleneck aromas; the mustiness disappeared by the second time I checked). I wonder what else Joe has stored in his attic...
 
Hilarious. Has this person ever forgiven you for bring that?

Just goes to show you, that one persons exploding skunk ass (among other things) is another persons favorite on the table.
 
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
Yeah, Jesus, the godforsaken cohort of newbies that joined up subsequently is unbelievably tedious.

No, wait ...

Wanting old people back is not the same as dissing new people. On the other hand, that was a classic thread and I miss it--just like I miss the good old days when I had to walk 5 miles through the snow uphill both ways to get to and from school.
 
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
Yeah, Jesus, the godforsaken cohort of newbies that joined up subsequently is unbelievably tedious.

No, wait ...

Wanting old people back is not the same as dissing new people. On the other hand, that was a classic thread and I miss it--just like I miss the good old days when I had to walk 5 miles through the snow uphill both ways to get to and from school.

That original thread was 99 on WLDG, right? I can't remember except that I wasn't 30 yet. That'd be a fun find if someone will look it up.
 
When was this Oswaldo? I've been in Boston all week! I need to sign up for that live feed of planned Overnoy sightings in selected metropolitan areas.

I forgot all about SY and this wine. Man, does that bring up some good memories.
 
Rob Adler was at that jeebus with Yaniger and that wine. He has told me that the wine was way worse than what the tasting note describes. Hearing both Rob and Stuart tell the story was tear-inducing hilarious.

best...tasting...note...ever
 
originally posted by VLM:
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
Yeah, Jesus, the godforsaken cohort of newbies that joined up subsequently is unbelievably tedious.

No, wait ...

Wanting old people back is not the same as dissing new people. On the other hand, that was a classic thread and I miss it--just like I miss the good old days when I had to walk 5 miles through the snow uphill both ways to get to and from school.

That original thread was 99 on WLDG, right? I can't remember except that I wasn't 30 yet. That'd be a fun find if someone will look it up.

It was on Wine Therapy, I think. It led to Stuart's early departure from the board. I don't know if it survived.
 
Wow, I have long admired that paragon of tasting notes, but had forgotten what wine it was about. I am truly honored to have tasted the subject of the greatest tasting note of all time. I am obviously not as sensitive to the smell of merchant marine captains.

originally posted by .sasha:
When was this Oswaldo?

Last night in São Paulo, as soon as I got the wine out of quarantine.
 
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
Yeah, Jesus, the godforsaken cohort of newbies that joined up subsequently is unbelievably tedious.

No, wait ...

Wanting old people back is not the same as dissing new people. On the other hand, that was a classic thread and I miss it--just like I miss the good old days when I had to walk 5 miles through the snow uphill both ways to get to and from school.

Just joshin'.
 
originally posted by Oswaldo Costa:
Last night in São Paulo, as soon as I got the wine out of quarantine.

Ah! I had assume the place of origin was a bar/restaurant and that you had tasted in situ.

Quarantine? Apparently local customs had no trouble looking up that old tasting note either.
 
originally posted by MLipton:
originally posted by VLM:

That original thread was 99 on WLDG, right? I can't remember except that I wasn't 30 yet. That'd be a fun find if someone will look it up.

Ask and ye shall receive.

Mark Lipton

It is WLDG. So much for my memory. But wasn't there a furious exchange on Wine Therapy when Robert took serious objection to this tasting note?
 
Back
Top