On the futility of wine writing

Saina Nieminen

Saina Nieminen
"Many of the people who came to us were of the kind who would be a nuisance anywhere but have special opportunities in a bookshop." Among bookshop keepers this is the most famous George Orwell quote, much more so than those Animal Farm or 1984 ones that are commonly mentioned. But those of us who survive in the business longer than Orwell did, survive largely because we not only see the nastiest (and smelliest!) customers on the planet; we see the nicest, most warmhearted ones, too.

I have one regular customer who doesn't talk much but he buys and sells good books and seems like an uncommonly sweet personality. I even give him a 10% discount these days. Somehow he found out that I like wine, so now, before going north for Christmas, he came to our shop for the last time this year and gave me a bottle of wine for Christmas.

Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 - Napa Valley; 14,5% abv
What surprised me most is how after such circumstances my critical faculties completely failed. This smelled and tasted lovely with a chunk of bloody lamb. But without this feeling of being appreciated so much that a regular customer would give me such an expensive bottle, I am sure I would not have enjoyed such a minty, oaky, chocolatey, sweet, candied yet extracted wine as this. Yet I honestly did enjoy it. And this is why all wine writing is futile. And since I'm unable to lie about overcoming such feelings, this is why I'll never be a pro in wine writing! Today, this is awesome. I suspect that tomorrow I would call it spoofy and say nasty things about it.
 
true. in the same manner, the wines of a given region/producer taste better and offer more enjoyment after visiting the place, meeting vignerons, walking the vineyards, etc.

that being said, i don't bother to go to places or visit producers that are in the spoof business.
 
Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet 1987 is tremendous. And there are some green notes mixed in there. The 1992 PR Cab is one I have always liked, and I think is an example of how to do chocolate flavors without the fake fruit of spoof.

The Beringer Merlot from Bancroft Ranch on Howell Mountain may be one of the most underappreciated wines in the world today, in terms of the vintages of the 80s and early 90s. Amazingly ageable.

Anyway, I've definitely liked my share of Beringer reds, even if I don't post about them much, seek out current vintages, or highly regard the whites. Anyone try the White Merlot lately?

But I guess I seem to be missing the real point of Otto's post, which I also appreciate. Wine can be a touchstone for a kinds of related thinking and journeys of the mind. Often it isn't, and usually there is some kind of faux-scientific analysis employed to render what appears to be the ultimate word. But you knew that already.
 
One of the greatest wines of my life was the Freixenet in the glass my wife held as we toasted each other, our arms intertwined, on our wedding day.
 
originally posted by Levi Dalton: Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet 1987 is tremendous. ... The 1992 PR Cab is one I have always liked

Levi, And ditto the 1991 Private Reserve Cabernet which I still have a good bit of. I haven't tasted it in a while but a couple of years ago it was still going great guns.

. . . . . Pete
 
Does this mean that we're a bit confused at finding ourselves with our guard down and liking what we know isn't, i a given moment, politically correct?

Me, since I'm a producer of deeply incorrect purple wines, I don't have such qualms when I like a wine...
 
originally posted by VS:
Does this mean that we're a bit confused at finding ourselves with our guard down and liking what we know isn't, i a given moment, politically correct?

Me, since I'm a producer of deeply incorrect purple wines, I don't have such qualms when I like a wine...

No, it was just a momentary lapse on Otto's part. We are now back to our regular programming (pun intended).
 
Back
Top