A Couple of Weeks Worth

Bill Buitenhuys

Bill Buitenhuys
2006 Domaine Bourillon Dorlans Vouvray Sec Vieilles Vignes La Coule d'Argent (Loire) This is a new producer for me and Im glad to have tried it. Its more sec tendre than sec and extremely approachable at this young stage. It has plenty of waxy lemon and spiced pear flavors, good cut, and a brush of minerality. A pleasant acidic tingle on the back end is quite attractive as well.

2003 Domaine Les Hautes Nolles Muscadet Ctes de Grandlieu (Loire) Another producer I havent tried before. Quite fruit forward and rather round as one might expect from the vintage but the leesy melon flavors are intense and lengthy. Its lacking in salinity, mineral intensity, and acidity that I want in a muscadet, but again, thats not surprising. (After 2 weeks in the fridge this has much more of an acidic cut and isn't bad at all).

1996 Marqus de Riscal Rioja Gran Reserva (Rioja) Opened 4hrs prior to dinner (no decant), cork soaked all the way through. Intense aromas of fallen trees, damp dropped leaves, and dried violets leads into a wonderfully rich mouthful of silky dark sweet fruit and gritty tannins. The backend has a firm acidic lift and leaves with a bittersweet cherry trail. The last glass showed more rose water /floral tones and took on some cocoa powder flavor mixed with the fruit. Aromatically seductive now with no need to rush to open.

1971 Bodegas Toro Albala Don PX Gran Reserva (Montilla-Moriles) Ultra thick fig and raisin pie flavors with a welcomed splash of black tea and cardamom. Its super sweet but it does have decent cut so as to not make it cloying. A little goes a long way though.

In Monterey
2004 Ventana Vineyards Due Amici (Arroyo Seco) This 50/50 blend of sangiovese and cabernet sauvignon started with some high toned cherry aroma then tasted like red and dark fruit oozing through a Band-Aid. Its sharply acidic with some tongue searing heat finishing with a mouth full of fine grit tannins.

2003 Pietra Santa Sangiovese (Cienega Valley) Tart raw cranberry and sour cherry explosion that is enticing in its brightness but a bit hot at first. Over time, the heat mellows to rather attractive macerated cherries, licorice, hint of tobacco and a chalky mineral core.

Not in Monterey
2005 Domaine d'Orfeuilles Vouvray Les Coudraies (Loire) A very pleasing demi-sec with lovely lemony waxiness and floral tones and a rich texture that is still showing layers of babyfat over its acidic and mineral core. Quite enjoyable now but a bit round. On Day 2 (left without cork in the fridge) this wine is really beautiful. Its taken on more body and wooliness, the fruit is vibrant, and the acidity has pushed through. Hold for 3+ years for next bottle.

2001 Cline Cellars Zinfandel Live Oak Vineyard (Contra Costa County) This has matured into quite an elegant zin. In its youth it was exceedingly tannic and aggressive but it now shows subtle dried herbs and dried lilacs aromas and still has plenty of zin-berry flavors transitioning to a robust but finely grained tannic structure. The herby fruit finish is lovely as well.

2007 Fontanafredda Barbera Briccotondo (Piedmont) I love to find truffle notes in Piedmont wines but Im thinking tuber not confection. This was like letting a cinnamon dusted milk chocolate truffle melt in your mouth. The cherry fruit pushed forward over time and there was enough acidity to give it enough lift for red sauce but that chocolate core is far too distracting to make it something Id want again.
 
originally posted by Bill Buitenhuys:

2001 Cline Cellars Zinfandel Live Oak Vineyard (Contra Costa County) This has matured into quite an elegant zin. In its youth it was exceedingly tannic and aggressive but it now shows subtle dried herbs and dried lilacs aromas and still has plenty of zin-berry flavors transitioning to a robust but finely grained tannic structure. The herby fruit finish is lovely as well.

As a native of CC county and a longstanding fan of Zin, I've tried a lot of Cline's wines. I'm glad that you had such a good experience with this one. Lately, I've found Cline's Zins to be too soupy for my tastes, indicating either a stylistic shift at Cline or a morphing of my own tastes, or both. Have you had any recent Cline wines, Bill?

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by MLipton:
Have you had any recent Cline wines, Bill?
Mark Lipton

Mark-

Back in the day, I could always count on Cline for a decent QPR Zin when I had a jonesing for that genre. However, since about 2002 or so, I have not had a Cline Zin that was any good...too hot or too oaky or thin or all three. I've essentially given up on them.

Oh wait, you were asking the other Bill.

FWIW, I opened a 2001 ESJ Los Robles Viejo last evening that was in a very good spot (open and on my dinner table).

"The Other" Bill
 
1996 Marqus de Riscal Rioja Gran Reserva (Rioja) Intense aromas of fallen trees, damp dropped leaves, and dried violets leads into a wonderfully rich mouthful of silky dark sweet fruit and gritty tannins. The backend has a firm acidic lift and leaves with a bittersweet cherry trail... Aromatically seductive now with no need to rush to open.
I had their "plain" Reserva recently (2004 I think) and was quite impressed. Combined plump, ripe not overdone fruit with some of those traditional mellow woodsy Rioja qualities.

...like red and dark fruit oozing through a Band-Aid.
Now there's a tasty image. ;^)
 
originally posted by Redwinger:
originally posted by MLipton:
Lately, I've found Cline's Zins to be too soupy for my tastes, indicating either a stylistic shift at Cline or a morphing of my own tastes, or both. Have you had any recent Cline wines, Bill?
Mark Lipton

Mark-

Back in the day, I could always count on Cline for a decent QPR Zin when I had a jonesing for that genre. However, since about 2002 or so, I have not had a Cline Zin that was any good...too hot or too oaky or thin or all three. I've essentially given up on them...

Well, Matt Cline left Cline a few years ago. After making some quite good Zins and Rhone blends at Trinitas, he and his wife Erin have started their own gig, S3X Wines, found here: http://www.s3xwines.com/home.html. The only wine I've tasted so far from them was, oddly enough, a late harvest Riesling. But it was delicious.
 
originally posted by Redwinger:

Back in the day, I could always count on Cline for a decent QPR Zin when I had a jonesing for that genre. However, since about 2002 or so, I have not had a Cline Zin that was any good...too hot or too oaky or thin or all three. I've essentially given up on them.

Oh wait, you were asking the other Bill.

FWIW, I opened a 2001 ESJ Los Robles Viejo last evening that was in a very good spot (open and on my dinner table).

Hey, any Port in a storm, y'know? Your experience mirrors my own, 'Winger. And thanks for the input on the Robles Viejos -- I was rooting around in the cellar last night (apropos for an erstwhile root cellar) and came across two bottles of that stuff, along with 3 (!!) '01 W-Fs. And with cooler weather upon us it's time to break out the big reds.

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):

Well, Matt Cline left Cline a few years ago. After making some quite good Zins and Rhone blends at Trinitas, he and his wife Erin have started their own gig, S3X Wines, found here: http://www.s3xwines.com/home.html. The only wine I've tasted so far from them was, oddly enough, a late harvest Riesling. But it was delicious.

Ah, so! That explains why I've only heard talk of Fred Cline in recent years. I'll have to see what S3X is all about.

Thanks!
Mark Lipton
 
Mark, I tried a couple different Cline zins from '03 and '04 but they didn't leave a positive impact. This '01 Live Oak was nice.

Hey other Bill, ditto the thanks on the '01 LRV note. I need to open another one soon.
 
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):
I had their "plain" Reserva recently (2004 I think) and was quite impressed. Combined plump, ripe not overdone fruit with some of those traditional mellow woodsy Rioja qualities.
I don't think I've ever had the reserva but it's on the shelves around here. Thanks.
 
originally posted by Bill Buitenhuys:
2003 Domaine Les Hautes Nolles Muscadet Ctes de Grandlieu (Loire) Another producer I havent tried before. Quite fruit forward and rather round as one might expect from the vintage but the leesy melon flavors are intense and lengthy. Its lacking in salinity, mineral intensity, and acidity that I want in a muscadet, but again, thats not surprising. (After 2 weeks in the fridge this has much more of an acidic cut and isn't bad at all).

This is one of the few Muscadets that has been available here - and I have quite enjoyed the '04 and '05. Especially the '04 was classically proportioned and a joy to drink. The '05 was a bit ripe but still fun. The '06 was however a horrible disappointment: flabby, overly fruity. I'm hoping we'll see the '07 soon.

-O
 
originally posted by MLipton:
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):

Well, Matt Cline left Cline a few years ago. After making some quite good Zins and Rhone blends at Trinitas, he and his wife Erin have started their own gig, S3X Wines, found here: http://www.s3xwines.com/home.html. The only wine I've tasted so far from them was, oddly enough, a late harvest Riesling. But it was delicious.

Ah, so! That explains why I've only heard talk of Fred Cline in recent years. I'll have to see what S3X is all about.

Thanks!
Mark Lipton

Also interested to hear this. I still have fond memories of the '97 Cline Zinfandel ($9.99!) so if he's making wine like that...
 
originally posted by Joel Stewart:
hope you didn't overbuy the barbera...
Thankfully it was a restaurant buy. Didn't ruin the meal but really didn't compliment it either. Actually it went pretty well with tiramisu.
 
Back
Top