Did you ever open a bottle by mistake....

Karen Goetz

Karen Goetz
....and be delighted once your selfish consternation subsides?

The other night I reached into my larder because I knew I had a 1996 Huet vouvray sec in there, a Clos du Bourg that I'd purchased at vintage release. It was time. I was ready. I grabbed the '96 Clos du Bourg and opened in in the half light of my darkened kitchen. Aromas flew out of the bottle and I smiled to myself... aaah. I had candles going and everything for a solo COVID dinner with myself. The room smelled like spices and spring onions and garlic from the Alaskan halibut I'd seared and braised until the flesh was barely translucent in the center and crunchy at the surface resting in the cast iron pan. I knew the center was perfect because the beautiful fish was just starting to collapse in its juices. I was curious to see how the richness contributed by the vineyard would merge with the richness of this splendid poisson. And how the cut of the sec would rub nicely against the fat grain of the fish in the gustatory diversion of this particular intercourse.

I poured a short amount into my glass and admired its golden hues: crystal clear but molten, honeyed gold. 1996 was a non-botrytis year. Raising the glass to my fervent lips I had a moment of doubt as the bouquet registered way too rich for sec... or maybe it had begun to oxidize and lose its balance? The aromas were fresh and mineral but felt almost oily in my nose. I took a sip and for a split second I was confused at the opulence. Goddammit has this bottle lost its structure to age and laziness?

But I was wrong. In the next flash I knew I had opened the wrong bottle and sacrificed one of my few 1er Trie, Moelleux Clos du Bourgs. Ach. Scarcity can make one hold on too tightly to material things.

I almost laughed at my mistake and I wondered how this wine would be as part of a meal, not as dessert or a separate course afterwards. The bottle was stunning with dinner. It melded with the fish. It was one of those experiences where the food and wine together become their own creature. Haunting but precise presence in each other's company. And I got to experience it by total accident.

The wine's minerality (white, crushed stone) was not muted by its richness (not sweetness, too simple a descriptor for this complexity!). It was ardent and self-composed at the same time. This wine had a fine bead of acidity that kept it light on its feet. No heaviness whatsoever and the "oiliness" was a tactile sensation in both mouth and nose that provided elasticity against the spices and minerals. It was like a ripe pear on a tree that just got stung by a bee.

Reader, I married them.
 
Fantastic note, Karen. I have certainly grabbed the wrong vintage of a particular wine by accident on several occasions but not quite this scenario. On a separate note, I appreciate hearing about this wine as I have one remaining bottle of it (the other was badly corked). It sounds like it’s in a good place now, though I have little doubt that it’s nigh unto immortal. So, drink and hold, as they say?

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by MLipton:
Fantastic note, Karen. I have certainly grabbed the wrong vintage of a particular wine by accident on several occasions but not quite this scenario. On a separate note, I appreciate hearing about this wine as I have one remaining bottle of it (the other was badly corked). It sounds like it’s in a good place now, though I have little doubt that it’s nigh unto immortal. So, drink and hold, as they say?

Mark Lipton

Mark,
Yeah. It was really lovely, precious, really, in a sensory way not a value way.
 
originally posted by Karen Goetz: Did you ever open a bottle by mistake.... Scarcity can make one hold on too tightly to material things.

Karen, powerfully true.

Nice note.

. . . . . . Pete
 
I don't know that I've ever done this or had that wine. But the account was like a small bit of the second half of Jane Eyre, with the appropriate ending. Thanks.
 
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:
Great note, Karen.

About the halibut... seared then braised? How does it stay crisp if it's been braised?

If you do it carefully and flip it once, then don't turn it the bottom side gets seared to the pan, even with the juices/wine bubbling around it. Need a cast iron skillet.
 
originally posted by Karen Goetz:
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:
Great note, Karen.

About the halibut... seared then braised? How does it stay crisp if it's been braised?

If you do it carefully and flip it once, then don't turn it the bottom side gets seared to the pan, even with the juices/wine bubbling around it. Need a cast iron skillet.
I see. I'll have to try it. Thanks.
 
If her goal was, as she said, that "the flesh was barely translucent in the center and crunchy at the surface" then the Air Fryer is a good option albeit without the liquid. Roasting is not necessarily better but rather just another option.

. . . . . . Pete
 
originally posted by Peter Creasey:

If her goal was, as she said, that "the flesh was barely translucent in the center and crunchy at the surface" then the Air Fryer is a good option albeit without the liquid. Roasting is not necessarily better but rather just another option.

. . . . . . Pete

that's totally different than what she referring to though. braising can produce a crisp skin with a sauce. frying wont achieve that
 
originally posted by Bill Lundstrom:
originally posted by Peter Creasey:

If her goal was, as she said, that "the flesh was barely translucent in the center and crunchy at the surface" then the Air Fryer is a good option albeit without the liquid. Roasting is not necessarily better but rather just another option.

. . . . . . Pete

that's totally different than what she referring to though. braising can produce a crisp skin with a sauce. frying wont achieve that

Air frying is to braising as Vajra is to 'thank god' bottles.
 
originally posted by Tristan Welles:
originally posted by Bill Lundstrom:
originally posted by Peter Creasey:

If her goal was, as she said, that "the flesh was barely translucent in the center and crunchy at the surface" then the Air Fryer is a good option albeit without the liquid. Roasting is not necessarily better but rather just another option.

. . . . . . Pete

that's totally different than what she referring to though. braising can produce a crisp skin with a sauce. frying wont achieve that

Air frying is to braising as Vajra is to 'thank god' bottles.

i dunno. if i found Vajra Rosso on an otherwise crappy list at a fair price i would probably whisper "Thank God"
 
karen, some of us here have a good friend who got himself in position to be the wine buyer for his college at one of the two particularly well known universities on the british isles, with the privilege of being able to buy direct from the wineries.

he was particularly happy to secure quantities of huet sec (this must have been in the 80s) for an all-college dinner, to go with a salmon course.

the wine was quite sweet, causing an uproar.

in the weeks to follow, a representative of the domaine, on his trip to uk, dropped by the university and declared the wine to be a mislabeled moelleux, en masse.

an orthogonal story to yours, no?
 
originally posted by Pavel Tchichikov:
karen, some of us here have a good friend who got himself in position to be the wine buyer for his college at one of the two particularly well known universities on the british isles, with the privilege of being able to buy direct from the wineries.

he was particularly happy to secure quantities of huet sec (this must have been in the 80s) for an all-college dinner, to go with a salmon course.

the wine was quite sweet, causing an uproar.

in the weeks to follow, a representative of the domaine, on his trip to uk, dropped by the university and declared the wine to be a mislabeled moelleux, en masse.

an orthogonal story to yours, no?

Great story, my friend. Since AFAIK, students aren’t given an opportunity to be the cellar master at Cambridge, it rather falling to a senior faculty member, I presume that this took place at that other institution of learning. (My uncle Kurt was for many years the cellar master at Clare College, a position I exploited for my own benefit on those few occasions when he invited me to join him at high table)

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by Jayson Cohen:
Fabulous vignette, Karen. And a great wine—one of my favorite Huet Moelleux.

Jason,

I was surprised that it went so well with the meal I prepared (as a dinner companion!). The experience challenged my assumptions about moelleux beauties.
 
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
I don't know that I've ever done this or had that wine. But the account was like a small bit of the second half of Jane Eyre, with the appropriate ending. Thanks.

Delighted, Jonathan.
 
Back
Top