Is there a better Syrah on the planet tonight than the 2007 Baker Lane Sonoma Coast Cuvée?

Eden Mylunsch

Eden Mylunsch
Maybe not on your planet, but on my planet this wine is pretty great. Granted, it’s not in a lineup festooned with 1989 Gentaz or 1991 Chave or any vintage of any Syrah made by Sine Qua Non, but with its bacon and black pepper and more than a hint of mint and just a bit of barnyard and perfect balance, it’s tasting pretty damn good to me right now. Balanced and light on its feet despite its 14.2% alcohol, it’s pushing the right buttons on the ol’ sensory Univac tonight.I don’t know how much to ascribe its showing on the fancy newfangled Reidel Syrah glass a friend recently gave me. It’s got that muffin-top thing happening with it where it’s got that roll down at the bottom of the glass bell, not unlike when I cinch my belt real tight and my belly kind of flops over the top and I’ve got to wear my shirt untucked so it doesn’t look like I’m some fat old cow who’s been eating too much ice cream and going AWOL from the Pilates classes. I guess there’s some science behind this weird hitch-in-the-getalong of the svelteness of this glass—apparently it was originally developed by the guy who founded Zalto (his new company is called Josephine) but Reidel’s version is just different enough to avoid getting the patent attorneys involved.

But the main thing is that this wine tastes better in this glass than it does from my usual stemless Flintstone’s jelly jar, even from just a 375 ml bottle maybe would a 750ml bottle would taste twice as good? The Baker Lane Sonoma Coast Cuvée was made from fruit grown in Sebastopol, CA for an owner who knows the difference between wine-that’s-good-to-drink-with-food and wine-that-scores-big-points. It was made by a winemaker who was pretty good but has a reputation for being a little eccentric -- the last I heard, he’d moved to a bunker in Mendocino County with a cache of gold bullion to live off the land and await the presumptive takeover by the commies and socialists (and this was years before the rise of Trumpism and the ensuing prevalence of Caymus and Josh Cabernet on the retail shelves.)

And in a not-unrelated subject, I’ve been listening to a lot of Pepper Adams lately. A fair amount of Leo Parker too, and it’s interesting to debate the merits of either baritone saxophonist with other people who care (um, both of them?) and I find that, even discounting Harry Carney’s contribution to the instrument’s Q-Factor (he was a goddamn big-band player, after all), that I fall firmly in the Pepper Adams camp. His work with such a broad array of musics (salsa and the decaying entrails of hard bop is exceptional) is impressive, to say the least, while Parker was a little mired in his expansion of the old-school section players (see Harry Carney’s oeuvre). But ultimately, when the topic is baritone sax, someone is going to bring up Gerry Fucking Mulligan. (does someone maybe wanna get David Lillie on the line for this discussion?) Jeru was an a mazing, barrier-breaking horn guy for sure, but in the long run, will he be remembered for blowing into a big curved hunk of brass or for his arrangements and compositions and coming up with the idea of leaving the piano player at home? Same question about Charles Mingus and this bass vs. composer thing, and by the same token, even Jaco Pastorius, whose bass work absolutely changed the way we bassists think about our instruments exponentially more than Mulligan did with the bari sax, but Jaco was quite the composer too, whether despite or because of his bipolar problems. In 200 years, music’s going to be all about synthesizers and AI composition, so people like Mulligan, Mingus and Pastorius will likely be remembered more for the way they sequenced notes into memorable melodies than for the way they manipulated notes out of their instruments. But does the absence of other qualifiers lessen the impression of quality found in one example of a semi-crowded field? Can a chimpanzee be a pretty great ape if you’re ignoring the 600 pound gorilla in the room?

In the absence of other really expensive, profoundly unobtanium wines on my table from the likes of Chave, Gentaz, and Steve Edmunds, this wine, on this night, and in this glass, was the greatest wine on the planet. And did I mention that it was a really marvelous accompaniment to an Olympia Provisions Käsekrainer? (on sale at Whole Foods this week, but they’re three to a package, not four like their hot dogs, which are also amazing). Not to muddy the waters further, but I prefer my Käsekrainer hot- dog style with mustard and catsup, and a little pickle relish. They don’t do relish at Bitzinger’s stand in Vienna, but I’M NOT IN VIENNA, AM I? and you can’t have everything, can you? Good version of the sausage though, and while dining on sausage and Syrah I’m leafing through a book on Tony Duquette instead of ascending the stairs to see what’s playing at the Albertina this week.

-Eden (and speaking of muddying the waters, I’m listening to “Muddy Waters, Folksinger” tonight. This MoFi LP is ungodly real-sounding, like some old guy set up to play in your ***********, and it sounds real enough to scare the hell out of both cats and send them running from the room when he starts singing. And this is on a upper mid-fi system if I had the kale for a serious stereo it’d probably sound like Jesus was playing in his backup band)(well, it might be said that He already does, given the esteem with which I hold bassist Willie Dixon, who plays on a couple of tracks)
 
Saturday night we had a 2018 Guy Farge Saint-Joseph Terroir de Granit. Light but complete and complex. No makeup. This is wine of another age, seldom encountered today. Drunk alongside a 2004 Robert Michel Geynale, and there was no winner, save those doing the drinking.
 
originally posted by Florida Jim:
‘Finish the bottle, did we?

Well yeah, it was only a half bottle. It's not as if I pounded a mag of Mollydooker and began waxing rhapsodic about the 3L bottle of 1964 Masi Mazzano Amarone that Hugh Johnson and I polished off one night after Vin Italy along with a 2 kilo wheel of Basajo. As with competitive hot dog eating contests, it all seems fine at the beginning and you can keep up the pace and trade stories with great zest and relish (although note that few competitive eaters gum up their tubesteaks with relish or onions, as stomach space needs rationing after just a few red hots go down the chute. And with wine and cheese, it's a cumulative effect, moreso than with other foods because the alcohol affects the brain cells and what seemed attainable early in the evening (ie: mass consumption) because an "eyes are bigger than one's stomach" situation later. And don't get me wrong, Hugh's a great guy but if you've heard his story about the night he was playing strip poker with the Queen and the freakin' POPE "stopped in for biscuits" you don't really need to hear it twice. Or four times, as about halfway through the bottle (and a third of the way through the cheese) he'd run out of other things to talk about. I tried to get him onto the subject of whether the Mesopotamians had placed bottles of wine inside the Pharoah's tombs in the pyramids just to mess with generations of downstream Egyptologists (the Mesopotamians were left the keys to the 'rids so they could come in and dust on a regular basis but they got weirded out by the Sphinx -- "Why's that cray-cray cat peepin' at us that way, huh?" and after a couple of centuries they stopped coming around.)

So 375ml isn't that bad on the overserving front. If it'd been a whole bottle maybe I would have gone on to explain to youse how the Silicon Valley Bank fell victim to a two-pronged effort to bring them down. Prong One was a long-running trademark battle with the Silicone Valley bank (motto: "We're the breast bank in town") who had recently lost their infringement suit against SVB (the Silicone Valley Bank pres was quoted in the Hawaii Surf News over the weekend as saying "hey bra, we're still expanding, we're not boobs!) The other party was a subsidiary of the Trilateral Commission, using a financial sledge hammer to kill a mosquito because one of the SVB startups was an iPhone app that uncovers conspiracies, governmental or otherwise. What better process for removing conspiracy theory finder-outers than to put together a conspiracy to take 'em out?

-Eden (maybe tonight I skip the wine and dive into Jason Wilson's latest Everyday Drinking post on variations on the Manhattan using peanut butter flavored booze instead of vermouth)
 
Thanks for the lulz, Eden, and sorry I wasn’t there to join you for the Syrah and Käsekrainer.

Gonna scurry off now and find some Pepper Adams to listen to.

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by MLipton:
Thanks for the lulz, Eden, and sorry I wasn’t there to join you for the Syrah and Käsekrainer.

Gonna scurry off now and find some Pepper Adams to listen to.

Mark Lipton

one possible selection: Donald Byrd's album 'Royal Flush'. In addition to Byrd and Adams you'll find Herbie Hancock, Butch Warren and Billy Higgins.
 
originally posted by Pavel Tchichikov:
Is there a better Syrah on the planet tonight than the 2007 Baker Lane Sonoma Coast Cuvée?

yes, wind gap russian river syrah 2008

Ah, from the good ol' days, when Pax was trying to beat Raj at the "my syrah is smaller than your syrah" game while distancing himself from the he-man wines he made under the Pax label. Was the Wind Gap the one that came in at around 10% or 11% alcohol? As I recall it was great with fish tacos.

-Eden (not so great with a steak, wherein it might have come played an invigorating role in the pairing similar to that flitting piccolo part played over the brass in the middle section of Sousa's "Stars & Stripes Forever" but in this case it just kind of serves as a high-toned distraction, lessening the appreciation of the meat itself and interfering with one's awareness of the wine on its own)(and maybe we can talk about Dave Alvin's early vocalizing at a later date -- he, like Pax, has figured it out and both are rightfully stars of their respective oeuvres)
 
“Oeuvres”
Pretty fancy lingo.

While I have no doubt that your baby bottle was worthy of your soliloquy and that Wind Gap is certainly worth a paragraph or two, the Donald Byrd fan in the house has whipped up a few dandies from that grape. And I don’t believe he was even entered in the race toward diminutive Syrahs.
(He just did his Mr. Natural impression and kept on keeping on.)
Best, Jim
 
i'm surprised that in this whole discussion jamet, allemand, levet, bernard faurie, and/or noel verset have not been mentioned.
 
originally posted by robert ames:
hmmm, i don't know. for me it is enough that their wines do.
You just don’t understand the lonely wino with no place to go, a good bottle in front of him and the need to speak. And clearly you don’t dance.
-sigh-
 
originally posted by Florida Jim:

You just don’t understand the lonely wino with no place to go, a good bottle in front of him and the need to speak. And clearly you don’t dance.
-sigh-

I don't understand them either, but sometimes they just need to be let out into the sunlight, if only to give housekeeping an opportunity to air the joint out for a minute.

-Eden (I've been told that Thierry Allemand can cut a rug with the best of 'em)
 
originally posted by Eden Mylunsch:
originally posted by Florida Jim:

You just don’t understand the lonely wino with no place to go, a good bottle in front of him and the need to speak. And clearly you don’t dance.
-sigh-

I don't understand them either, but sometimes they just need to be let out into the sunlight, if only to give housekeeping an opportunity to air the joint out for a minute.

-Eden (I've been told that Thierry Allemand can cut a rug with the best of 'em)
How about that?
I know he does a carbonic cuvée every year and then adds to his wines as needed. So I figure he’s a cha cha kind of guy.
 
Back
Top