No luck with Tuscany or Sicily

SteveTimko

Steve Timko
2005 Benanti Etna Rosso di Verzella - Italy, Sicily, Etna DOC (6/18/2009)
Day 1: Sourness dominated the flavor after I pulled the cork. Badly out of balance. After 90 minutes a single flavor started to poke through the acid. It was oak. I set it aside for the next day.
Day 2: The wine has mostly come into balance, but still needs food. Strong dose of oak still prominent. Dark ruby red in color, pencil shavings on the nose and darker fruits and maybe licorice on the palate. Average finish. Not really distinguishable as an Italian wine, let alone nerello mascalese from Sicily. It did improve quite a bit in 24 hours, so I'm assuming it will improve with age. The Palari Faro was supposedly spoofy without much bottle age and maybe this wine is on the same trajectory 13.5 percent alcohol. The bottle says the vines are head trained.. A Wine Warehouse import.

2006 Rocca delle Mace Sasyr Toscana IGT - Italy, Tuscany, Toscana IGT (6/9/2009)
It's amazing to see positive notes for this wine in other vintages. On the nose, I got alcohol and acid. Lots of acid. For the palate, the wine flows with a mangled mess of indistinguishable flavors across the taste buds on the attack like a flat tire -- plonk, plonk, plonk, plonk, plonk. And then on the finish there's this ugly flair of alcohol that kicks your taste buds in the rear end before sliding down the gullet. It's supposed to be a blend of sangiovese and syrah -- a blend I never tried before -- and I couldn't distinguish either grape. Perhaps the bottle was heat damaged. It looked interesting on the menu at Olive Garden. It's a brand new Olive Garden that opened up. I wanted to try it at least once. Hey, it's my life. My money. It's close by. I don't have to explain to you why I'm eating at the Olive Garden SCREW YOU! A Palm Bay International Import.
 
originally posted by SteveTimko:
It's supposed to be a blend of sangiovese and syrah -- a blend I never tried before

What? You don't drink Brunello? My condolences re your dining and drinking experiences, Steve.

Mark Lipton
 
Benanti is great. Really. Amazing bottles come from the house of Benanti. Jaw droppers. Best of all of Italy sort of bottles.

But Benanti is also inconsistent. And hard to find. And expensive. And the wines don't show well young.

But...well, I mean, Benanti is great.
 
originally posted by Thor:
Jaw droppers. But also inconsistent. And hard to find. And expensive. And the wines don't show well young. But great.
You should do their PR.

I already do, as far as Manhattan at this particular moment in history is concerned.

Recently, I have put glasses of Benanti in front of Sharon Bowman, SF Joe, the editor of Gastronomica, Tim Kopec of Veritas, the Manhattan restaurant laison for Zachy's, Gregory dal Piaz, Jamie Wolff of Chambers Street, Giovanni Manetti of Fontodi, one of the Vinifera gang, and my entire staff, amongst several other guest type people.

As they have no one bringing the wines into New York at this moment, it's just me in my little Benanti Alamo.
 
originally posted by Levi Dalton:

Recently, I have put glasses of Benanti in front of ... SF Joe...
Sure was impressive stuff, speaking of whites from Europe in 2003. Of course, the vineyard is almost out of Europe so the vintage may not signify to the same degree. But still remarkable stuff. Thanks much for that glass.
 
originally posted by Levi Dalton:

As they have no one bringing the wines into New York at this moment, it's just me in my little Benanti Alamo.
How in the Sam Houston do you get ahold of the wines?
 
originally posted by Levi Dalton:

But Benanti is also inconsistent. And hard to find. And expensive. And the wines don't show well young.

I described this wine on Wednesday night on my Facebook page as tasting like box wine. So it improved quite a bit by Thursday. How many more years until this wine might start showing well?
Have you had luck with the Rosso di Verzella bottling before?
Any other wines by Benanti to look for?
 
originally posted by SteveTimko:
originally posted by Levi Dalton:

But Benanti is also inconsistent. And hard to find. And expensive. And the wines don't show well young.

I described this wine on Wednesday night on my Facebook page as tasting like box wine. So it improved quite a bit by Thursday. How many more years until this wine might start showing well?
Have you had luck with the Rosso di Verzella bottling before?
Any other wines by Benanti to look for?

For me, the really amazing wine from Benanti is the Pietramarina, a white made from 80 year old Carricante vines planted in the volcanic soil of Mount Etna. The more I taste it, the more I love it. It is perhaps the greatest white wine being made in Italy today.

I have posted here (or Therapy?) in the past about aged Lamoremio and the straight monovarietal Nerello Mascalese, both of which were excellent. Currently, I am mightly impressed with the Il Drappo '04, which is quite beautiful and will only hold future charms for those looking in.
 
I already do, as far as Manhattan at this particular moment in history is concerned.

Recently, I have put glasses of Benanti in front of Sharon Bowman, SF Joe, the editor of Gastronomica, Tim Kopec of Veritas, the Manhattan restaurant laison for Zachy's, Gregory dal Piaz, Jamie Wolff of Chambers Street, Giovanni Manetti of Fontodi, one of the Vinifera gang, and my entire staff, amongst several other guest type people.

You are an incredible and insatiable name dropper.
 
originally posted by Yixin:
I already do, as far as Manhattan at this particular moment in history is concerned.

Recently, I have put glasses of Benanti in front of Sharon Bowman, SF Joe, the editor of Gastronomica, Tim Kopec of Veritas, the Manhattan restaurant laison for Zachy's, Gregory dal Piaz, Jamie Wolff of Chambers Street, Giovanni Manetti of Fontodi, one of the Vinifera gang, and my entire staff, amongst several other guest type people.

You are an incredible and insatiable name dropper.

That just shows you the humble approach I take to wine. I am humble because I name drop. Or so the logic goes.
 
Back
Top