Capmartin 2007 Pacherenc du Vic Bilh Sec (Southwest France) Very aromatic, and in an intriguingly elusive way. Flowers? Whitewashed rock? Herbs? All and none of those things, I suppose; this is not a wine that wishes to be nailed down. Theres just enough structure to give it support, and an interesting crescendo to the finish. Nice. Id consider holding it for a short while to see if it develops some wax and texture, except that the synthetic closure virtually guarantees a short life. (9/09)
Jadot 2006 Gevrey-Chambertin (Burgundy) Surprisingly harmonious at this stage and given the in-your-face nature of the structure. But harmony there is, which I suppose bodes well. Soil is rich brown and light dusk, fruit is fulsome and berried, and both tannin and acidity are hard to miss. At the right price, this could be a solid choice. (8/09)
Mas de Libian 2008 Vin de ptanque (Ardche) Bretty and twisted. I think theres a rough little quaffer in there somewhere, but the wines not clean enough to know. (9/09)
Domaine La Berangeraie 2005 Cahors Cuve Maurin (Southwest France) Impossibly dense and virtually impenetrable, a post-rockfall coal mine of a wine, with smoke, black earth, tar, rosemary, and not-yet-discernable fruit. Do not approach. (9/09)
Larose-Trintaudon 2001 Haut-Mdoc (Bordeaux) Wretched and tired. This is certainly past it, but its past cant have been any good either. (8/09)
Jadot 2006 Gevrey-Chambertin (Burgundy) Surprisingly harmonious at this stage and given the in-your-face nature of the structure. But harmony there is, which I suppose bodes well. Soil is rich brown and light dusk, fruit is fulsome and berried, and both tannin and acidity are hard to miss. At the right price, this could be a solid choice. (8/09)
Mas de Libian 2008 Vin de ptanque (Ardche) Bretty and twisted. I think theres a rough little quaffer in there somewhere, but the wines not clean enough to know. (9/09)
Domaine La Berangeraie 2005 Cahors Cuve Maurin (Southwest France) Impossibly dense and virtually impenetrable, a post-rockfall coal mine of a wine, with smoke, black earth, tar, rosemary, and not-yet-discernable fruit. Do not approach. (9/09)
Larose-Trintaudon 2001 Haut-Mdoc (Bordeaux) Wretched and tired. This is certainly past it, but its past cant have been any good either. (8/09)