TN: Snow tires

MarkS

Mark Svereika
No, not the flavor of rubber in wines (although I've had that before), but living north of the Mason-Dixon there comes a season when one best replaces summer rubber with winter wear, as was done this week. This is when one knows that fall is "done" and one enters the nether season betwixt faded fall and not-quite-anything.

Brun, Beaujolais, 'l'Ancien', 2009
Like the Cat-in-the-Hat's Fun-in-a-Box but with only Thing 1 instead of both mischief makers, this is really fun juice for the price (under $15) but doesn't have what you need or want for holding interest or to place in the cellar. (It's got a plastic cork, for Mahmet's sake!) It is what it is, and that's not a bad thing to be. Better the first night that the two or three subsequent. A-

Fritz Hirtzberger, Wachau, Riesling, Singerriedel, smaragd, 2001
An almost painful minerality pervades this bottle from the get-go, to the point where I wonder if that is all there is? Yeah, there's citrus galore, zest of all kinds, and a searing finish of chalk and limestone, but the profile almost speaks of gruner veltliner more than riesling. Or are these interchangeable in Austrian eyes? Still, good and a glass of elegance. 13.5% A-

Alesia, Pinot Noir, Green Valley of Russian River Valley,2007
My first Kevin Harvey wine, and I can see why he sells out from mailing list only even in this tough economy. Rose petal and maraschino cherries on the exuberant nose, sweet candied cherries with spiced, mulled oranges, and good balancing acidity. becomes more serious with airtime, but I still wouldn't want to age this too much past 5 or 6 more years. On the finish, dusty barrel/oak dust tannins. [Note: cork completely twisted and 'snapped' upon opening and the ah-so couldn't retrieve the half that got stuck in the bottle, which promptly fell into the liquid. Anyone else have problems with Rhys corks?] Good, although I worry about aging these with the cork being so dry. A-

Quinta Vale D. Maria, Douro, 2004
Dark strawberry-cherry red color. Earthy cherry, plum licorice aromas. Meaty and savory flavors, cherry, and a touch of licorice and sweet guava paste and leather on the finish. Modern and bigger than the 14.5% on the label, which hits at the end. Retains balance, but not something I'll seek out again. B+

Vestini Campagnano, Terre del Volturno IGT, 'Kajanero', 2005
Bias revealed: I like this winery. That said, this is nothing ambitious and a bit of an everyday drinker. Roses, soft plums and cherry on the nose and palate, with a slight astringent bite on the finish. Simple, and yet delicious. 13% B/B+

Marcarini, Barolo, 'la Serra', 1999
Tense, nervous strawberry-unsweetened raspberry puree with an iron-rust finish. Taut. Perhaps young by a few years? B+/A- 14%

Chateau de Fieuzal, Pessac-Leognan, 2000
Youthful, purplish red colored. Cedary blackcurrant nose, on the palate followed by slightly austere fruit with a touch of wood, but having good depth on the end. Not bad, nor overblown. B+
 
originally posted by MarkS:


Fritz Hirtzberger, Wachau, Riesling, Singerriedel, smaragd, 2001
I like this better than you did, though you do prefer it to several other wines.

To me it is a great wine from a great site in a great vintage, and it is still quite young. Other than richness and ripeness from the aforementioned characteristics, I don't see the stylistic straight line to Honivogl, nor have I noticed a Wachau indifference to cepage.

Really, you should maybe try it again or try it in a few years? I fear you underestimate the wine.

Or you should sell the rest of your stash to me.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
originally posted by MarkS:


Fritz Hirtzberger, Wachau, Riesling, Singerriedel, smaragd, 2001
I like this better than you did, though you do prefer it to several other wines.

To me it is a great wine from a great site in a great vintage, and it is still quite young. Other than richness and ripeness from the aforementioned characteristics, I don't see the stylistic straight line to Honivogl, nor have I noticed a Wachau indifference to cepage.

Really, you should maybe try it again or try it in a few years? I fear you underestimate the wine.

Or you should sell the rest of your stash to me.

Stash? Well, if my sole other bottle counts. Definately on the young side, although the color is darker looking than I thought it would be. It was elegant, but for the price of these, I expected a bit more in the glass. I will revisit in about 4-5 years.
 
Mark,
FYI, the Alesia label is no more.
Kevin is not buying grapes from anyone these days, hence everything will bear the Rhys label.
Best, Jim
 
originally posted by SFJoe:

To me it is a great wine from a great site in a great vintage, and it is still quite young.
Only had the 01 Singerriedl once, but I fully agree - a bottle of that last year is among the most memorable wines I've ever had.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
originally posted by MarkS:


Fritz Hirtzberger, Wachau, Riesling, Singerriedel, smaragd, 2001
I like this better than you did, though you do prefer it to several other wines.

To me it is a great wine from a great site in a great vintage, and it is still quite young. Other than richness and ripeness from the aforementioned characteristics, I don't see the stylistic straight line to Honivogl, nor have I noticed a Wachau indifference to cepage.

Really, you should maybe try it again or try it in a few years? I fear you underestimate the wine.

Or you should sell the rest of your stash to me.

I've probably mentioned this a couple of times, but I attended a great tasting of ~25 "dry" 2001 rieslings from Austria, Alsace and Germany (blind), with a wonderful educated group and plenty of time to ponder, and wines like singerriedel, fx kellerberg and ried schutt weren't even close, too much of a good thing, basically. Sorry. The likes of Achleiten, Bodenstein, Steinerhund were the stars.
 
originally posted by .sasha:


I've probably mentioned this a couple of times, but I attended a great tasting of ~25 "dry" 2001 rieslings from Austria, Alsace and Germany (blind), with a wonderful educated group and plenty of time to ponder, and wines like singerriedel, fx kellerberg and ried schutt weren't even close, too much of a good thing, basically. Sorry. The likes of Achleiten, Bodenstein, Steinerhund were the stars.

Absent from your list is anything from Trimbach -- did they not make the grade? -- and when did Toni Bodenstein become a vyd? or are you saying that he has the Midas touch with dry Riesling?

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by MLipton:
originally posted by .sasha:


I've probably mentioned this a couple of times, but I attended a great tasting of ~25 "dry" 2001 rieslings from Austria, Alsace and Germany (blind), with a wonderful educated group and plenty of time to ponder, and wines like singerriedel, fx kellerberg and ried schutt weren't even close, too much of a good thing, basically. Sorry. The likes of Achleiten, Bodenstein, Steinerhund were the stars.

Absent from your list is anything from Trimbach -- did they not make the grade? -- and when did Toni Bodenstein become a vyd? or are you saying that he has the Midas touch with dry Riesling?

Mark Lipton

Both Hune and Fred 375th anniversary were very closed on that day. I did pick them out pretty much, but had to be fair. And this is coming from a Trimbach fan of nearly Viking proportions here.

Bodenstein is not a bottling ? Someone help me out here, I have some wonderful friends who have served me what I have believed to be one, on both continents.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
originally posted by .sasha:
The likes of Achleiten, Bodenstein, Steinerhund were the stars.
I hear you.

Fortunately, the cellar has both flavors.

and quite possibly, for different decades.
 
originally posted by MLipton:
Absent from your list is anything from Trimbach -- did they not make the grade? -- and when did Toni Bodenstein become a vyd? or are you saying that he has the Midas touch with dry Riesling?

Mark Lipton
I think the Wachstum Bodenstein vineyard was planted in 1990. But wouldn't disagree on the Midas touch, particularly after that '95 Prager Achleiten Riesling that Kirk opened a couple of weeks ago.
 
Tony bottles a "Wachstum Bodenstein" from a very high (450m) parcel in what is known as the Hinterseiber vineyard. Riesling for quite a while now, and recently also GV. It is high and cold and gives lean but powerful wines.

He got the riesling from all over the place in a refutation of the adapted-to-the-place selection massale philosophy.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
Tony bottles a "Wachstum Bodenstein" from a very high (450m) parcel in what is known as the Hinterseiber vineyard. Riesling for quite a while now, and recently also GV. It is high and cold and gives lean but powerful wines.

He got the riesling from all over the place in a refutation of the adapted-to-the-place selection massale philosophy.

Joe, where are you getting your info on this single vineyard Wachau stuff? Or is it just from the producer's website?

Is there a book/website on the Wachau in general that you're using? The only book I know on Austrian wine is good, but very producer-focused and doesn't much discuss the vineyard designates, have topographical maps of the Wachau, or any other such nerdy treasures.
 
originally posted by Morgan Harris:

Joe, where are you getting your info on this single vineyard Wachau stuff? Or is it just from the producer's website?
Oh, I just make it up.

Or if you're being charitable, I can't remember where I heard it all.

I don't have any Wachstum Bodenstein older than '99.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
originally posted by Morgan Harris:

Joe, where are you getting your info on this single vineyard Wachau stuff? Or is it just from the producer's website?
Oh, I just make it up.

Or if you're being charitable, I can't remember where I heard it all.

I don't have any Wachstum Bodenstein older than '99.

Hah, I don't mean to sound like the inquisition, I just like to keep a tab on the possible study resources out there, if there were any to be had.

I would feel comfortable giving you as a citation.
 
originally posted by Morgan Harris:

Hah, I don't mean to sound like the inquisition, I just like to keep a tab on the possible study resources out there, if there were any to be had.

I would feel comfortable giving you as a citation.

Oh, I don't dismiss authoritative sources, I just don't have any for you on this one. I reference the '99 because it gives a sense of the minimum age of the vineyard. The vines are still fairly young.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
originally posted by Morgan Harris:

Joe, where are you getting your info on this single vineyard Wachau stuff? Or is it just from the producer's website?
Oh, I just make it up.

Or if you're being charitable, I can't remember where I heard it all.

I don't have any Wachstum Bodenstein older than '99.

I go0t my info from David Schildknecht, back when he used to visit NC. It is the same info Joe has.

1999 is the first year and technically could have been jungferwein.
 
Amazing how great the 2001 is for such young vines.

I should pull a '99. Maybe tomorrow.

Meet y'all in the cellar?
 
Back
Top