Maipo, Savigny, Pavia, Belgium, Bourgueil, Franciacorta, Alsace

Saina Nieminen

Saina Nieminen
Quatrovinos Sigla 4 2008
A blend from Maipo of Syrah, Cab Sauv, Petit Verdot; 14% abv. Very dark. It smells of blackcurrant juice with a slight savoury twist. Full bodied and fruity but nicely tannic and with adequate acidity. The 12 months in oak only show a little. It is ok for a Chilean wine, but I am not hugely excited. But it is good to see something slightly different being made in Chile.

M. Doudet-Naudin Savigny-lès-Beaune 1er Cru Les Serpentières 1999
Elegantly rustic. Perhaps more Musar than Savigny, however. Not overtly bretty to my tastes, however.

Le Fracce Villa Rajna Pinot Nero Provincia di Pavia IGT 2009
An uncomplicated and fun wine that gave me much pleasure: sweet aromas, typical of the grape, some pleasant tartness.

Westvleteren 8
I thought it quite boring despite some interesting funky/animal aromas: sweet, soft, not crisp enough to really be interesting. Why this is considered the holy grail of Trappist beers is incomprehensible to me. I'll stick to Orval.

Yannick Amirault Bourgueil La Coudraye 2009
13% abv. Dark fruit, very ripe but gladly not too ripe, some nice tobacco and earth aromas. Dry and refreshingly tannic, has enough fruit to be drinkable now, but ideally should see a bit more age for the tannins to become less drying; moderate acidity; rich and full bodied for a "basic" cuvée. Very nice and wonderfully perfumed even though I usually prefer a less slick and less ripe style of Cab Franc.

Ca' del Bosco Franciacorta "Satèn" 2005
39,90; 12,5% abv; 70% Chardonnay, 30% Pinot Bianco; aged for at least 46 months before disgorgement

I love Bl de Bl Champagne and I have long heard that Ca' del Bosco's "Satèn" is supposed to be one of the better Chardonnay-dominant wines from outside Champagne and that it is in most years very like a Bl de Bl Champagne.

And, for once, its reputation seemed true! At first it had lovely apple and mineral aromas; it gets strong bread aromas quickly after opening. Crisp, racy and steely yet there seems to be sun/fruit coiled up inside this structure that is bursting to get out. If Pierre Peters made fizz in a warmer/sunnier place, I can imagine it tasting like this. Great stuff, and considering the general price of fizz in Finland it isn't even as drastically over-priced for this quality as most others!

Trimbach Gewurztraminer 2007
14% abv; 4,4 g/l acidity; 9 g/l RS

I must admit first of all that I rarely enjoy this grape; but I must also admit that my experiences with Ribeaupierre have almost made me a convert.

This "basic" Gewurz isn't as interesting as the Ribeaupierre, but I still liked it. The scent is sweet and spicy - my "madeleine" that always takes me back to the souqs of Damascus and Aleppo. Rich and sweetish (but not cloying and not such a sucrosity that I would have thought RS; instead it manifested itself more as what just healthy, ripe grapes are like; but perhaps there isn't an organoleptic way to distinguish them), but refreshing though not very acidic. Very clean and pure finish. Nice!

After work I didn't feel much like cooking so I bought some takeaway Indian chicken curry. Though not a hot curry, the alcohol of the wine was accentuated by the spices and the match was certainly not good. I do like a Nebbiolo with curry, but generally I think high alcohol wines just do not work with spicy food.

Since a big chicken curry isn't quite enough for two, I did make a side of spinach with nutmeg - and that did work well with the wine. The slight bitterness of the food and the slight sweetness of the wine completed each other.
 
I'm with you Otto, on the favorite trappist front, as my love of Orval is no secret. I have had a couple good experiences with the Westvleteren Blond, which in my experience is much better than the 8 or the 12. It however, may not taste as "rare" which I'm sure makes a lot of difference to many tasters...

The more time goes by, the less I like dark, strong, sweet belgian-style beers. Even a 12oz glass is way more than I can drink of most of them.

Cheers,

Kevin
 
Oops, Westvleteren 8 should not taste animal - there is something wrong here. It should small of allspice, yeasts, cane / brown sugar and weath. It is really complex, like a Houillon made beer, on the palate. Very drinkable.

As delicious as is, Orval should come over as one-dimensional against the Westvleteren.

I agree with you that strong Belgian beers can be on the sweetish side. But don't need to be. Like wine, one needs to let them compelxify in the bottle. Triple Westmalle remains, after 8-10 years in the bottle, a stunning drink. I once had a 1955 from this Brewery ... It was for hardcore lovers but really, really nice!
 
As luck would have it, less than a week after talking about how I vastly prefer the Westvleteren Blonde to its rarer brothers, a co-worker whom I've been helping beerhunt (from afar) while he was on a 2 month work gig in Belgium, drops off none other than a fresh bottle of Wesvleteren Blonde. He knows my preferences well, but didn't know my opinion of the blonde compared to the 8 and 12, but as he was dropping off the goods, he tells me "I could have brought either of the other 2, but this one is more fun to drink." I couldn't have said it better myself...

And as a bonus a bottle of Fantome Noel, and an elusive Fantome glass, I've been looking for one for years. Score!

I have varying experiences with Westmalle tripel, I've had blindingly good bottles, and others that are alcoholic boozebombs. I wouldn't call Orval one-dimensional, but can see people not loving it. Probably my favorite thing about Orval is that though each bottle is a little (interestingly) different, but they all taste like Orval.

Cheers,

Kevin
 
Back
Top