I've got +/- 30 vintages of Chignard under my belt (obviously, the bulk of those were with Michel, the father of Cedric) and this is the most disappointing vintage I can remember. The VA didn't bother me (I'm fairly insensitive), but the wine, while not terrible, lacked the usual precision and charm. The good news is that this, my favorite Fleurie producer, is back on track with 2009.