I did as well, but I think they had just come in and were probably a bit out of sorts.
The more important thing was that Jo compared 2010 to 2002 and 1996 at dinner. (!!!!!) Those are my archetype vintages for Muscadet. I like other vintages for different reasons, but for wines I drink every year, I return to 2002 and to memories of 1996 (mine are long gone).