Four Little Burgs

Oswaldo Costa

Oswaldo Costa
Drinking pretty much solo these days, so picked up a few halves of inexpensive, locally available Burgs, and came to them with correspondingly low expectations.

2009 Bertrand Ambroise Bourgogne 13.0%
Hooray, screw caps in Burgundy, even if at the low end. Not bad aromas of sour cherry and iodine. Decent zip, good balance, surprisingly tannic, but with a dark flavor streak that I can’t place, and that, combined with a sour finish, obstructs the kindling of pleasure. Don’t know this producer, but he bottles several Grand Cru and 1er Cru vineyards.

2007 Jean-Marc Boillot Bourgogne 13.0%
Attractive crushed rose petals and bright red berries. Juicy, fruity, zippy and bouncy, like curls jumpy with dippity-do. Simple, but hits the limbic sweet-spot. Delivers pleasure with the simplicity of folk wisdom. Vanishes in a jiffy, following the consequential inevitability of elemental truths.

2008 Frédéric Magnien Côte de Nuits-Villages Croix Violette 13.0%
Bottleneck smells oaky and international. In the glass, smells like reduced NZ pinot. Aeration improves the reduction aromas. Tastes chocolaty, caramelly, ideal for cola palates. Has acidity, but it’s strident and disjointed, perhaps added. Bah. Maybe it’s in a dumb phase, but there’s little to suggest intelligence down the road.

2008 Frédéric Magnien Marsannay Ronsoy 13.5%
After the Croix Violette, expected to hate this too, but didn’t. Nose is pretty closed (aeration did nothing to improve it, unlike reduction), but tastes surprisingly acceptable. Before food, shows good body and balance, with civilized alcohol and no sense of oak. Should be quite drinkable in a few years. With food, loses its balance, but retrieves it when back on its own. Went down fairly rapidly, suggesting that the senses were more receptive than the mind.
 
Thanks for the notes Oswaldo. And I know how you feel about drinking solo, it sucks. My wife can now drink after delivering about a month ago and it's much more fun now !

Regarding Ambroise, I have to say I'm not a big fan at all. They're not bad wines at all but to me they taste quite modern. Always ripe and with some wood...
 
originally posted by Oswaldo Costa:
Postcards from the ledgeWould you have told me to only buy the Boillot?

there are so many guys named Boillot out there. Some of them are even related. I can't keep track of them, but one of them is excellent. The Rosenthal one.
 
Belated HUGE congratulations, Arno, I had no idea. Boy or girl?

Alas, I'm expecting a drought after the birth too, because the milk can't be wineladen, or oxidative, etc., etc.
 
originally posted by .sasha:
there are so many guys named Boillot out there. Some of them are even related. I can't keep track of them, but one of them is excellent. The Rosenthal one.

I have well liked the couple of wines I have had from Jean-Marc Boillot. Whites, though.

Henri of the same last name is also respectable.

There are others, and a search of Rosenthal's producer list shows one in the Côte de Nuits, of the first name Louis, which I do not know.
 
originally posted by Oswaldo Costa:
Alas, I'm expecting a drought after the birth too, because the milk can't be wineladen, or oxidative, etc., etc.

Exactly. My wife's drought is still going 9 months after delivery for these reasons. But she's fastidious about these things.

I have some bottles ready for her that we may get to in another 3-6 months!
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:

Exactly. My wife's drought is still going 9 months after delivery for these reasons. But she's fastidious about these things.

Of course she is: she's German! [insert emoticon of choice here]

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by Oswaldo Costa:
Belated HUGE congratulations, Arno, I had no idea. Boy or girl?

Alas, I'm expecting a drought after the birth too, because the milk can't be wineladen, or oxidative, etc., etc.

Thanks Oswaldo! It's a little girl.
 
originally posted by MLipton:
originally posted by Rahsaan:

Exactly. My wife's drought is still going 9 months after delivery for these reasons. But she's fastidious about these things.

Of course she is: she's German! [insert emoticon of choice here]

Mark Lipton

I know you're joking, but FWIW I'm not a big fan of ascribing personality traits to nationalities. It's a dynamic that is so heavily prone to confirmation bias and has nothing to say about the endless areas in which my lovely German wife is a sloppy mess.
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:

I know you're joking, but FWIW I'm not a big fan of ascribing personality traits to nationalities. It's a dynamic that is so heavily prone to confirmation bias and has nothing to say about the endless areas in which my lovely German wife is a sloppy mess.

Yup. As someone with quite a bit of extended family in Germany (among other places) I've seen firsthand how misleading any generalization about cultural characteristics can be, though as usual there's usually a kernel of truth within each one. With that in mind, you've no doubt heard the old saw:

In Heaven:
The police are English
The mechanics are German
The cooks are French
The lovers are Italian
It's all organized by the Swiss

In Hell:
The police are German
The mechanics are French
The cooks are English
The lovers are Swiss
It's all organized by the Italians

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by Sharon Bowman:

There are others, and a search of Rosenthal's producer list shows one in the Côte de Nuits, of the first name Louis, which I do not know.

you know Ghislane Barthod ? Same cellar.
 
originally posted by .sasha:
originally posted by Sharon Bowman:

There are others, and a search of Rosenthal's producer list shows one in the Côte de Nuits, of the first name Louis, which I do not know.

you know Ghislane Barthod ? Same cellar.

husband and wife
 
Yes, husband and wife.

Is the Jean-Marc Boillot Bourgogne available anywhere in NYC? Free version of Wine Searcher yielded no results.
 
I visited Jean-Marc Boillot about 20 years ago, so my knowledge is not recent. Except that I still see the wines here.

Like Sharon, I much prefer his whites. When I visited him we tasted the 1990s. The red Bourgogne A.C. was being sourced from a plot just outside Volnay at that time.

He told me he did a 25% saignee on his reds - and these were from 1990(!). I've always figured that was why I was less enthusiastic about them.

Now that I think about it, even though I still see his wines here, I don't recall seeing the regional cuvee recently.
 
well, producers often evolve and change their styles - even Ambroise is reported to be making much less modern wines now than in the 1990s and so on.
 
Back
Top