TN: Gentaz, Passat and Huet show up for dinner at Mark's.

Brad Kane

Brad Kane
Like a moth to a flame, resistance was futile when Mark Anisman started waving around a bottle of '90 Gentaz-Dervieux as an inducement to come over to his stylish Yountville home for dinner. I certainly would've settled for far less, but playing hard to get certainly has its rewards. Lou and BettyLu Kessler also came over and my last evening in Napa was a most enjoyable one.

2009 Bera Vittorio E. Figli- Moscato d'Asti Canelli
Sweet, but not overly so. Lively and refreshing with peach and passion fruit flavors and aromas dominating, with hints of white flowers. A lovely starter. A-/B+.

1990 Gentaz-Dervieux- Côte-Rôtie, Cuvée Réservée Côte Brune
What a wonderful and rare treat. One must mourn a little when opening a bottle from the master as one realizes there are fewer and fewer bottles left in the world. The wine was wonderful. Alive, vibrant and ever changing. The nose started off with an intensely bloody meat aroma that quickly shifted into the bacon fat realm and then the ripe red fruit part of the spectrum before harmonizing into a perfect synthesis of all of the above. On the palate the fruit was ripe, but not heavy or roasted. In fact, the wine showed a very Burgundian personality in it's sophistication, silkiness and weight without being heavy. Really singing right now with similar flavors as aromas with the addition of light spice and iodine notes that lurk in the background. No harm in holding them longer if you have them, but I really like where the fruit levels are now and the balance. Solid A.

1990 André Passat- Hermitage
A bit of an oddball wine. Mark opened this and explained to us that this wine is apparently a second label of Jaboulet and that this is really the La Chapelle, but the different labeling is done for tax purposes. That said, it didn't taste much like the '90 La Chapelles I've had in the past. On the nose were roasted red fruit, meat and spice aromas. It was a bit coarse and clumsy on the palate with no real definition. The fruit came off as being a little weak and the alcohol stood out just a touch on the finish. Drying tannins on the finish and all in all the wine just seemed a bit banal. B.

1989 Huët- Vouvray Cuvée Constance
My last half bottle of a group that I sourced from Europe eleven or twelve years ago. For the most part they've all shown more advanced than from 750, but while that's also the case with this one, it's also one of the best showings from .375 that I've had. The color is noticeably darker than it has been in the past, though not even close to being in the same realm of say a '90 Foreau Reserve. Beautiful aromas and flavors of ripe apricots, earl grey tea, orange marmalade, mineral, marzipan and a dollop of shoe polish. Certainly sweet, but a little less so than previous bottles and it's of course balanced impeccably by its acid backbone. Still youthful even from this bottle, so 750's should still slumber, or have a long decant. Gorgeous wine.A.
 
Never tasted a Gentaz, but am trying to be patient. A bottle of '89 that came up on WineBid a couple months ago sold for over $600, so acquiring one that way appears increasingly unlikely.
 
originally posted by Brad Kane:

1990 Gentaz-Dervieux- Côte-Rôtie, Cuvée Réservée Côte Brune
What a wonderful and rare treat. One must mourn a little when opening a bottle from the master as one realizes there are fewer and fewer bottles left in the world. The wine was wonderful. Alive, vibrant and ever changing. The nose started off with an intensely bloody meat aroma that quickly shifted into the bacon fat realm and then the ripe red fruit part of the spectrum before harmonizing into a perfect synthesis of all of the above. On the palate the fruit was ripe, but not heavy or roasted. In fact, the wine showed a very Burgundian personality in it's sophistication, silkiness and weight without being heavy. Really singing right now with similar flavors as aromas with the addition of light spice and iodine notes that lurk in the background. No harm in holding them longer if you have them, but I really like where the fruit levels are now and the balance. Solid A.

Fantastic lineup of wines, Brad. Those Napa folk know how to have a good time. I've highlighted one passage in your description because it exemplifies what Côte-Rôtie should be and so rarely is these days (Gentaz's wines being the exemplar, natch). The best C-Rs in my experience are feminine and perfumed, showing the more nuanced side of Syrah (or was that Serine?). These days, I'm hard to pressed to find any producer following that model, though there are a few producers I haven't yet tried (pricing being another problem, sad to say).

Mark Lipton
 
While it's currently fashionable about these parts to bash Cote Rotie of more current vintages, I think maybe the brush used should be a little narrower - there are certainly wines made with a heavy hand in the cellar, I would not paint the whole AOC with that proverbial brush.

Good wines made with some finesse can be found from Barge, Jasmin, Vernay, Pichon, Faury and even some of the new punks like Otheguy and even Lafoy-Gasse. Not to mention fellow disorderly Texier and even from time to time the Jamets. I find nothing at all wrong with 1998 or 2001 Jamet as examples.

But I do understand the appeal of wringing of hands and wishing for the past...I wish Gentaz and Trollat were still around making wines, and I remember when they were under 20 euros. And I used to walk 15 miles to school each way, uphill both ways, too.
 
originally posted by mlawton:

Good wines made with some finesse can be found from Barge, Jasmin, Vernay, Pichon, Faury and even some of the new punks like Otheguy and even Lafoy-Gasse. Not to mention fellow disorderly Texier and even from time to time the Jamets. I find nothing at all wrong with 1998 or 2001 Jamet as examples.

Mike,
I do appreciate what you're saying and even more the names you've put out there. As I said, I by no means have an exhaustive picture of what's going on there, much as I wish I could, but my infrequent samplings of what's being produced there have not been at all encouraging. Which Vernay is this you're referring to? Georges, or some other? I also see that JLL promotes Clusel-Roch as his STGT poster child in C-R, but my one exposure wasn't convincing. As for Jasmin, his wines have been more polished than those of Gentaz. Has that changed in recent years?

Mark Lipton
 
I Yes, Vernay was Georges. I also saw that JLL loves Clusel-Roch but I can't say that I share his opinion, at least from what I've tasted which is several vintages in the 1998-2004 range. Maybe something has changed, or maybe not. I see also lots of love for Levet in various places but that's the wrong end of the horse for me. As far as Jasmin vs. Gentaz - I certainly see a difference between them, my word wouldn't be polished but I really like Jasmin. Hard to compare new vs. old too - not much new Gentaz to correlate.

I certainly wish that there was more wine to my taste from all the areas of the Northern Rhone (not just Cote Rotie) but unfortunately there's a number of larger producers/negociants in each AOC who produce wines of minimal character - but others like them so they will not be going away anytime soon.

Maybe someone needs to come along and "raise the quality of winemaking". Oh wait, someone already did. Maybe we need someone to undo it and "lower the quality of winemaking"???
 
originally posted by mlawton:
I Yes, Vernay was Georges. I also saw that JLL loves Clusel-Roch but I can't say that I share his opinion, at least from what I've tasted which is several vintages in the 1998-2004 range. Maybe something has changed, or maybe not. I see also lots of love for Levet in various places but that's the wrong end of the horse for me. As far as Jasmin vs. Gentaz - I certainly see a difference between them, my word wouldn't be polished but I really like Jasmin. Hard to compare new vs. old too - not much new Gentaz to correlate.

Thanks, Mike. Some day I'm going to get my butt to Ampuis for the Marché, but until then I'll rely heavily on second-hard reports given how few opportunities I get to taste those wines.

I certainly wish that there was more wine to my taste from all the areas of the Northern Rhone (not just Cote Rotie) but unfortunately there's a number of larger producers/negociants in each AOC who produce wines of minimal character - but others like them so they will not be going away anytime soon.

Ditto. Lest I be thought of as a C-R basher, I should add that Hermitage is far more a wasteland for me these days. My last bottle of Chave is from '99 and I'm not totally confident of what to expect from it. Fortunately, the uptick in quality from St. Joseph, Crozes, Brézème (wink) and the Ardeche have taken up a lot of the slack for me. Cornas has more or less held steady in my life, with Verset fading out and Allemand ascending, not that they are comparable, either.

Maybe someone needs to come along and "raise the quality of winemaking". Oh wait, someone already did. Maybe we need someone to undo it and "lower the quality of winemaking"???

Noodle save us from "raises in the quality of winemaking." We've seen how much good that's done CA's wines, too. The lure of money will keep C-R and Hermitage tilting toward the Dark Side, I'm afeared. Generational changes seem to be favoring more traditional methods, it seems, so perhaps that'll ameliorate the problems somewhat.

Mark Lipton
 
I was recently disappointed by a taste of C-R apparently blended by Gentaz's former importer, so even that source--historically a font of so much brilliant Northern Rhone wine--now seems unreliable. Hard not to envy anyone who has access to the wines of Gentaz.
 
Back
Top