You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
shit show
- Thread starter Josh Beck
- Start date
U
Unknown
Guest
originally posted by Josh Beck:
You can disagree all you want but the Fourrier was overtly flawed, and not in a subjective way. If you think it will improve that says more about you than about the wine. The Esmonin was a shitpile that was miles out of my wheelhouse but you're free to go to bat for it all you want.
I also thought the 08 d'Angerville Champans sucked the other night, so go to town with that one :)
i didn't disagree with your opinions, i pointed out that they were worthless, and that you are talking out of your ass.
shut down burgundy tastes like shit. there's no news in that. some of it turns to gold, some of it gets merely tolerable, and some of it stays shit. everything you have said so far tells me that you have no idea at all whether the stupid shit you choose to drink at stupid times will stay shit or whether it won't.
you are of course welcome to parade your ignorance all you like, but there better boreds out there for that kind of shit. i mean, you might even win yourself a "you go girl," on eturd.com.
fb.
Jonathan Loesberg
Jonathan Loesberg
originally posted by fatboy:
originally posted by Josh Beck:
You can disagree all you want but the Fourrier was overtly flawed, and not in a subjective way. If you think it will improve that says more about you than about the wine. The Esmonin was a shitpile that was miles out of my wheelhouse but you're free to go to bat for it all you want.
I also thought the 08 d'Angerville Champans sucked the other night, so go to town with that one :)
i didn't disagree with your opinions, i pointed out that they were worthless, and that you are talking out of your ass.
shut down burgundy tastes like shit. there's no news in that. some of it turns to gold, some of it gets merely tolerable, and some of it stays shit. everything you have said so far tells me that you have no idea at all whether the stupid shit you choose to drink at stupid times will stay shit or whether it won't.
you are of course welcome to parade your ignorance all you like, but there better boreds out there for that kind of shit. i mean, you might even win yourself a "you go girl," on eturd.com.
fb.
Who knew that this wasn't disagreeing with opinions. You disagree n your usually impeccably arrogant and dismissive way, but that is still disagreeing.
Jonathan Loesberg
Jonathan Loesberg
originally posted by SFJoe:
Are we arguing about arguing again?
It's called metaphysics. I can't help myself.
Filippo Mattia Ginanni
Filippo Mattia Ginanni
originally posted by fatboy:
how do i know this? i know it because i've followed enough burgundy from vintages like 01 and 05 over the years to have some idea of how they develop. even mediocre crap from over hyped hacks like fourrier and s esmonin.
Love this, following 05 Burgs for 5 years in bottle. Built for the long haul. Ditto for the 01 with 9 years in bottle.
This thread is fucking hilarious. You guys crack me up. Keep going.
U
Unknown
Guest
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
Who knew that this wasn't disagreeing with opinions. You disagree n your usually impeccably arrogant and dismissive way, but that is still disagreeing.
mea culpa.
just for you, jonathan.
fb.
Jonathan Loesberg
Jonathan Loesberg
originally posted by fatboy:
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
Who knew that this wasn't disagreeing with opinions. You disagree n your usually impeccably arrogant and dismissive way, but that is still disagreeing.
mea culpa.
just for you, jonathan.
fb.
Although I am happy to defer to professionals on this issue, I believe that confession only does any good if it is accompanied by a resolution to amend. Still, a first step. Thank you.