Bitch

[Florida Jim]

The 1999 Vincent Girardin, les Amoureuses, is a clear demonstration of waste. Good site, good year, bad wine. Sour oak overwhelms.
In my dreams, this fruit goes to Barthod.
Best, Jim

 

[Ian Fitzsimmons]

Tant pis. I liked his 1999 Clos St. Denis very much, fwiw.

 

[John McIlwain]

Don't know if I'll ever get Girardin nor Perrot-Minot, come to think of it. So. Much. Lumber.

 

[MarkS]

Girardin has wasted many sites.

 

[SteveTimko]

I thought the rap on Girardin is that he has sites with good names but has bad position at those sites.
Supposedly he is no longer going to make reds. I've had better luck with his whites.

 

[Ian Fitzsimmons]

He was talking about giving up reds around the time I bought the CSD. If he's still doing so now, his credibility suffers.

 

[Jay Miller]

A pity, I have fond memories of his 1999 Bonnes Mares.

 

[Yixin]

originally posted by Jay Miller:
A pity, I have fond memories of his 1999 Bonnes Mares.

I don't. It's quite striking alongside the other suspects. Even the Potel was more potable.

 

[maureen]

I like his 1999 csd, beze, charmes, and bm very much - and really disliked his amoureuses and sold my bottles.