RTN: 1994 Domaine du Pere Caboche J P Boisson- Chateauneuf Du Pape, "Vieilles Vignes Elisabeth Chambellan"

Brad Kane

Brad Kane
Originally posted 1/28/01.

This was the first CDP I purchased. Back in the summer of '96, I had recently started working at a wine shop with Callahan and mentioned that I wanted to try something new. I had been mostly buying Cal Cabs and Bordeaux up to that point and he suggested this Chateauneuf. I have to say, it was a good recommendation and it went quite nicely with a braised lamb shank last night. My notes show that I paid $11.25 for the wine. I would assume the "normal" retail price was $14.99, or thereabouts. Makes one long for the old days.

1994 Domaine du Pere Caboche J P Boisson- Chateauneuf Du Pape, "Vieilles Vignes Elisabeth Chambellan"
A pretty ruby color in the light of a candle. Nice red fruit, pepper and light bacon aromas. On the palate, nicely integrated and drinking in prime time. The wine has a nice softness to it, yet remains solidly built. There's very enjoyable cherry, red raspberry, bacon and peppery flavors here. Silky and elegant. Very nice and an excellent value at the release price. A-/B+.
 
This was your first CdP? That explains the overrating. This is a nice value CdP that actually tastes like CdP. But it is always also sort of innocuous. Now that you've tasted some of the real stuff, you need to recant, or at least recount.
 
originally posted by Jonathan Loesberg:
This was your first CdP? That explains the overrating. This is a nice value CdP that actually tastes like CdP. But it is always also sort of innocuous. Now that you've tasted some of the real stuff, you need to recant, or at least recount.

I agree. The worst kind of mediocre wine.

It's grade inflation like this that makes our kids so fucking stupid.

This is exactly why I hate these recycled TNs.

This bored is about Core Wine Discussions.
 
originally posted by Brad Kane:
It was the first I bought, not tasted. Funny, some dude in Monkton and I seemed to agree on it.

The dude in Monkton knows a lot about the appelation and tastes a hell of a lot. But he has distinct diversionary tendencies, for instance a taste for highly spoofulated special cuvees. And if innocuousness isn't spoofulation for me, it also doesn't always lower his scores. He likes some things I like too, but I don't verify my opinions on that basis.
 
originally posted by Chris Coad:
Who is Elisabeth Chambellan?

Pere Caboche was originally owned by the Chambellan family way back when. Conflicting stories exist but I believe Elisabeth Chambellan first married Jean-Louis Boisson, thus bringing the vineyard into the family that currently owned it. Blacksmiths are involved somewhere too.
 
Back
Top