originally posted by Peter Creasey:
Arjun, It was a bit controversial. I was immediately surprised by the bouquet and, staying silent, asked Marc Perrin (sitting next to me) what he thought about the '01. He offered up that it seemed tired.
We vacillated a bit as to why it might be tired and finally decided it might have seen some heat at some point.
Interestingly, Marc and I both saved some of our '01 and when we revisited it later the slightly off-putting element in the bouquet had blown off.
So, initially a bit disappointing then ultimately what we were expecting from such a fine vintage.
I had an '01 from my own cellar a few weeks ago and it was superb and not showing any shortcomings.
In conclusion, if you have some, it should show well now while still on the upswing for a long life.
Amusing aside. During our conversation, it came out that 1970 was Marc's birth year. I chimed in that we'll have to get together again sometime as I have one last bottle of the 1970. He laughed and said, well, he had 300 magnums of the 1970. Needless to say, I was suddenly at a loss for words. (And, please don't misunderstand, Marc is a delightful, down-to-earth, salt-of-the-earth person who charmed everyone with his down home, bonhomie style.)
. . . . . Pete