Wine of the Year

Keith Levenberg

Keith Levenberg
I just got the new Wine Spectator. The 2017 Wine of the Year is the 2014 Duckhorn Three Palms Vineyard Merlot!

You might remember Duckhorn as one of the medium-priced brands on the type of chain restaurant wine lists last updated in 1993 where Kendall-Jackson chardonnay (WS's #28 wine of the year!) is one of the more everyday offerings and Opus One is there for high rollers. But don't be fooled, Three Palms Vineyard is fancy, top-of-the-line stuff. It's special because it's from a single vineyard.

What makes Three Palms Vineyard so special? Glad you asked! The WS reports that the main distinguishing characteristic is the three palm trees that grow in the middle of the vines. That's pretty distinctive indeed since we all know that vitis vinifera is native to Europe and the Caucasus while palm trees are, well, mostly "restricted to tropical and subtropical climates" (thanks Wikipedia). So Duckhorn found a pretty strange-- er, distinctive!--spot to grow merlot.

"Three Palms is a unique site for Merlot," the winemaker explains to Wine Spectator. "It's warm and rocky, and you really have to be on top of things there because Merlot is susceptible to hydric stress." You see, it's the CHALLENGES that make the site so special! Duckhorn manages the heat and hydric stress "through timely applications of water from drip irrigation."

And here you were probably thinking that supermarket wines don't have any terroir!

It's so nice we have the wine mags around to do shoe-leather reporting to turn up these undiscovered gems.
 
40 years ago, the Duckhorn 3 Palms Merlot was indeed one of the best examples of CA Merlot on the market. 3 Palms got sold, replanted (probably twice) and Duckhorn got Parkerized. What resemblance this version might bear to the prodigious '78 I have no idea, nor truth to tell am I at all motivated to discover.

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by MLipton:
40 years ago, the Duckhorn 3 Palms Merlot was indeed one of the best examples of CA Merlot on the market. 3 Palms got sold, replanted (probably twice) and Duckhorn got Parkerized. What resemblance this version might bear to the prodigious '78 I have no idea, nor truth to tell am I at all motivated to discover.

Mark Lipton

I agree, Mark, but you sure do know how to make a guy feel old.
 
originally posted by kirk wallace:
originally posted by MLipton:
40 years ago, the Duckhorn 3 Palms Merlot was indeed one of the best examples of CA Merlot on the market. 3 Palms got sold, replanted (probably twice) and Duckhorn got Parkerized. What resemblance this version might bear to the prodigious '78 I have no idea, nor truth to tell am I at all motivated to discover.

Mark Lipton

I agree, Mark, but you sure do know how to make a guy feel old.

If it's any consolation, '78 was the second vintage I bought.

Mark Lipton
 
originally posted by MLipton:
40 years ago, the Duckhorn 3 Palms Merlot was indeed one of the best examples of CA Merlot on the market. 3 Palms got sold, replanted (probably twice) and Duckhorn got Parkerized. What resemblance this version might bear to the prodigious '78 I have no idea, nor truth to tell am I at all motivated to discover.

Mark Lipton

1978 is only 39 years ago. I know this because I’m a 77er...

And also maths.
 
originally posted by Robert Dentice:

Bummer! When I saw the thread title I was expecting Keith's wine of the year!
New releases: 2014 Sociando-Mallet for QPR, 2014 Pichon-Lalande for absolute greatness, 2015 Jakob Schneider Niederhauser Kertz feinherb for the token white.
Mature wines: 1990 Leoville Las Cases and 1966 Petrus
Best food match: Assorted Navajos sherries (esp. the Oloroso #78) and a Puffeney savagnin at Bite of Hong Kong in Chinatown
Not actually wine: Pearls of Simplicity junmai daiginjo sake and L'Abricot du Roulot liqueur
Goodbye old friend: 2014 CRB rosé
 
originally posted by Keith Levenberg:
originally posted by Robert Dentice:

Bummer! When I saw the thread title I was expecting Keith's wine of the year!
New releases: 2014 Sociando-Mallet for QPR, 2014 Pichon-Lalande for absolute greatness, 2015 Jakob Schneider Niederhauser Kertz feinherb for the token white.
Mature wines: 1990 Leoville Las Cases and 1966 Petrus
Best food match: Assorted Navajos sherries (esp. the Oloroso #78) and a Puffeney savagnin at Bite of Hong Kong in Chinatown
Not actually wine: Pearls of Simplicity junmai daiginjo sake and L'Abricot du Roulot liqueur
Goodbye old friend: 2014 CRB rosé

Thank you!
 
originally posted by Keith Levenberg:

New releases: 2014 Sociando-Mallet for QPR, 2014 Pichon-Lalande for absolute greatness, 2015 Jakob Schneider Niederhauser Kertz feinherb for the token white.
Mature wines: 1990 Leoville Las Cases and 1966 Petrus
Best food match: Assorted Navajos sherries (esp. the Oloroso #78) and a Puffeney savagnin at Bite of Hong Kong in Chinatown
Not actually wine: Pearls of Simplicity junmai daiginjo sake and L'Abricot du Roulot liqueur
Goodbye old friend: 2014 CRB rosé

Gotta love autocorrect. And native American wines.
 
originally posted by Keith Levenberg:
Mature wines: 1990 Leoville Las Cases and 1966 Petrus

Sounds like I did not give me 90 LLC enough time when I thought I upgraded my 1990 collection by swapping it for others. Seemed a little square at the time.
 
originally posted by Pavel Tchichikov:
originally posted by Keith Levenberg:
Mature wines: 1990 Leoville Las Cases and 1966 Petrus

Sounds like I did not give me 90 LLC enough time when I thought I upgraded my 1990 collection by swapping it for others. Seemed a little square at the time.

Wondering if anyone else on this bored would really consider 1990 LLC mature? If from proper storage, I'd think it'd be anything but. Though, I stopped drinking wines from this estate more than a few decades ago.

BTW, Is "Pavel" a current alias for the dotster?
 
Mark, I'm not sure that "mature" is exactly the right word. The Leoville Las Cases '90 should be nicely within its drinking window but with plenty of time left and probably some room for improvement.

. . . . Pete
 
Back
Top