Flirting with and rejected by 2005

Rahsaan

Rahsaan
I bought 3 bottles of 2005 Simon Bize SlB Aux Vergelesses on release and tried to forget about them, but curiosity finally got the better of me. The initial pour tasted like aged woodsey orchard Burgundy, so I began to wonder if I had waited too long. But then it freshened up rather quickly with air, turning crisper and clearer in the frank young Burgundy fruit. Some nice suave 2005 material, and the nose is so deep, absolutely gorgeous, so there was pleasure. But overall it is crispy crunchy young Burgundy that is not yet in my zone. I guess the waiting continues!

Changing continents, I had an absolutely glorious final bottle of 2005 ESJ WF a few months ago, so then I figured why not open one of my bottles of 2005 ESJ Bassetti. The cork was beautiful and the aromas came flying out of the bottle, but the wine itself was minty crisp and structured and stayed that way for many many hours. Another bottle might be more giving, but I'll probably err on the side of waiting to open another.
 
Seems early for a Bize Vergelesses, especially in this vintage. Thanks for wading in and reporting. Personally, I'm trying not to think about my modest cache of 05s from good vineyards for a few more years.
 
A bottle of the 2005 straight village Bize SlB was completely ready to go this week. Either at peak or close. Really enjoyable. I think this was the first 2005 Burgundy for me that was even close to being at this stage.
 
originally posted by Jim Hanlon:
2005 Chandon de Briailles Ile des Vergelesses was pretty open and drinking well last week.
My son is vintage 2005 so I appreciate all datapoints on where the vintage is, particularly for Burgundy and the Mosel and Saar. Since he has got some of the C-d-B Ile des Vergelesses, perhaps I should see if he is willing to share one.
 
originally posted by Jim Hanlon:
2005 Chandon de Briailles Ile des Vergelesses was pretty open and drinking well last week.

Coming from Jim, I have to take this seriously. But having followed SLB AOC over two hours within the past year (a great village wine that's clearly on its way but definitely not quite there yet), I am puzzled.
 
I'd expect the C. de B. to be one for the long-term in the cellar, even more so than the Bize; but Maureen has occasionally observed that good red Burgundy passes through phases, showing well, then closing down; showing again, and again going dark. Maybe the 05 just surfaced briefly for air. I don't have enough bottles to do my own trial-and-error testing, alas, or I'd chime in with data.
 
originally posted by Pavel Tchichikov:
originally posted by Jim Hanlon:
2005 Chandon de Briailles Ile des Vergelesses was pretty open and drinking well last week.

Coming from Jim, I have to take this seriously. But having followed SLB AOC over two hours within the past year (a great village wine that's clearly on its way but definitely not quite there yet), I am puzzled.

To use a phrase I hate, the IdV wasn't "at its apogee," but it showed a nice mixture of pretty open fruit and early middle age complexity. It wouldn't surprise me to see a Pernand wine open earlier than a Savigny, but others here have much greater experience than I.
 
Back
Top