New Years Eve 2008

drssouth

Stephen South
New Years Eve 2008

In attendance
Steve and Barb South
Jeff and Dena Morris

Starter:
2007 Tintero Sori Gramella Moscato dAsti , alc 5%: A single vineyard Moscato...green tinged...soft and light with a delicate sweetness...lightly sparkling ..white fresh pears and a floral character.. not cloying in any way

With Cheeses: Manchego, Bucheron and Cathedral de Meaux

2007 Scholium Project Naucratis Lost Slough Vineyard (Verdelho), alc 14.9%: A little funky with waxiness upon first opening...fresh with a toastiness (always in stainless steel however) initially a little sweet but this disappates and it turns more serious with quince, rind, etc needs time to open up

With Roasted Cauliflower soup with black truffle oil

1989 Pierre Gimmonet et fils Les Cuvees de lan 2000 Champagne Brut, alc 12%
The very tiniest of bubbleshas the color of an aged still Chardonnayfresh baked bread on the nose great structurelemon curd, orange zest, early nuttiness and a chalky minerality on the palate a long finishseems right at the edge of showing secondary characteristics revisit in 10 yrs.

With Morris Farms Salad (home grown by Jeff and Dena except for the goat cheese and the walnuts and picked yesterday afternoon) baby carrots, green and red radish, beet leaves, white turnip, mix of lettuces, spinach, microgreen mix with a Dijon vinegarette.

1976er Fritz Haag Brauneberger Juffer-Sonnenuhr Riesling Auslese Goldkapsel, (375ml)
AP Nr 2 577 050 11 77 Dark golden colorinitially a little diesel/kerosene but it blew off quickly leaving a honeycomb/waxy character to the noseon the palate..dried apricots, peaches, crystallized ginger....the sweetness has fallen mostly away hovers above your tongue but on the finish it has silkly textureprobably at its pinnacle in terms of development (especially in the 12.7 oz bottle)

With Scallops with a asian pear, tawny port, bacon, cream and fennel sauce

1989 Domaine Zind-Humbrecht Tokay Pinot Gris Clos Jebsal Vendage Tardive, alc 13.75%: Shiny gold color nose of ginger, lime, etc.a lot of minerality with minimal sweetnessasian spice and ginger with citrus carry through on the palategreat with the scallop dish a really good showing for this wine

With Beef Tenderloin with a horseradish bread pudding, spinach with lemon and wild mushroom ragout

1996 Chateau Lynch-Bages, Grande Cru Classe Pauillac, ,alc 13% : Decanted for 4 hrs in the Rojaus expressive nose with graphite and cassisdelivers great pleasure on the palate with many black fruit flavors, nice texture/structure and fairly minimal tannins except at the very end of the finishclassic showing of a fine Bordeaux another wine showing very wellgreat with the medium rare beef

cranberry-ginger trifle for dessertno more wine at this point
 
1989 Pierre Gimmonet et fils Les Cuvees de lan 2000 Champagne Brut...seems right at the edge of showing secondary characteristics revisit in 10 yrs.

We had the 2002 Gimonnet Fleuron last night which was fine and correct but nothing exciting. I realize it is a different cuvee from yours but does it also need a bunch more age to become more interesting?
 
Interesting.

Maybe it needs a bunch less yields to become more interesting.

Gimonnet brags about doing 140 hectolires/hectare.
 
Gimonnet is nice but a little mass-produced these days. His NV "Cuis" is the best. We had a 2000 Extra-Brut Gastronome faced off with NV (2004) Ulysse Collin Extra-Brut and the latter blew away the Gimonnet with worlds more complexity, layers and depth.
 
originally posted by Sharon Bowman:
Posted before Joe, but I see some of the reason why. 140 hl/ha? Is this a new year's joke?

this was a "special" bottling for the millenium and was rumored to be from "selected lots"...not sure the real story

Rashaan...I would say this is just now becoming interesting (the '89) so if one could generalize..time is needed

Brad... we just didn't get to a Huet this evening... maybe soon
 
originally posted by Sharon Bowman:
Gimonnet is nice but a little mass-produced these days.

originally posted by Joe Dressner:
maybe it needs a bunch less yields to become more interesting.

Gimonnet brags about doing 140 hectolires/hectare.

That makes a lot more sense then. Thanks.
 
Back
Top