My top 3 wines of September.

Keith Levenberg

Keith Levenberg
J.J. Prum 2002 Wehlener Sonnenuhr Spatlese
Rocking bottle right from the get-go. To judge from the pale color alone you'd figure this was a new release. But it's moving nicely along its curve and has now reached the point where it tastes functionally dry despite carrying what must surely be an ample amount of RS. The fruit is all racy green apples. End result is textbook Mosel riesling with a rapier-like cut. I didn't notice until after getting this note down that I have an almost identical note on it from five years ago, so I'm guessing this is going to coast along like this for a long while.

Brick House 2008 Boulder Block Pinot Noir
Whole-cluster pinot from own-rooted vines planted in 1990. This was a bona fide holy-crap bottle. It was good ten years ago but I was completely unprepared for the league it's playing in now; in fact, I was mildly afraid that the somewhat disjointed personality it had on release would turn even more disjointed. Instead it's about as harmonious as pinot noir can be. There's an aromatic burst of ripe fruit from the pop of the cork but within a minute or two it's tamed itself into a mellow, brick-complexioned, semi-mature burgundian profile. The first sip brings that on with a texture that's pure butter and silk. Some snappy whole cluster signatures emerge after a couple of hours but I was surprised not to see them sooner and bolder. It had a strong green element on release that seems to have been mostly digested. But the leftovers the next day turn strongly evocative of forestal characteristics halfway between Old World sous bois and PNW pines.

Huet 2009 Le Haut-Lieu Sec
Epic performance, more impressive than I would have figured it had any right to be at just 11 years old. It's got a commanding presence right from the first sip - massive in scale and packed with personality. On the entry it has a chalky, gauzy texture so palpable it feels tannic, then on the back end it solidifies further into a crystal crunch. It's dripping with bright neon-yellow fruit so concentrated it feels like it ought to pour out like a slow treacle but it feels only barely sweet. Over the next couple days it slims down a bit without losing any character. You usually have to wait longer to get a Huet this profound.

honorable mention
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Jerome Galeyrand 2018 Les Retraits
My first 2018 Burgundy! From ~90-year-old vines in Comblanchien. Heavy CO2 that rates about a 7 or an 8 on the scale of 1 = still wine and 10 = wine stains on my ceiling. You gotta shake it out. Then it's just about the purest, most lip-smacking essence of pinot fruit it's possible to imagine. As vibrantly fresh as if you're knee-deep in the stomping vat but developed enough to have that saucy old-vine sève. I just wish the price hadn't doubled over the last 3 years.
 
originally posted by Keith Levenberg:
This was a bona fide holy-crap bottle. It was good ten years ago but I was completely unprepared for the league it's playing in now

God I love those kind of bottles. Except for the fact that they are too often the last ones in your cellar.
 
I opened a 2002 Prum WS SL earlier this year and concur. I was surprised at its stage of development, which seemed rapid to me, for a Prum, and am doubly-surprised to read that it was at or near this stage five years ago. But a very lovely bottle, in any event.

Have you by chance opened a 2005 edition?
 
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
I opened a 2002 Prum WS SL earlier this year and concur. I was surprised at its stage of development, which seemed rapid to me, for a Prum, and am doubly-surprised to read that it was at or near this stage five years ago. But a very lovely bottle, in any event.

Have you by chance opened a 2005 edition?

FWLIW I opened a 375 of the 2005 Auslese about 3 years ago and it was nowhere near ready.
 
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
I opened a 2002 Prum WS SL earlier this year and concur. I was surprised at its stage of development, which seemed rapid to me, for a Prum, and am doubly-surprised to read that it was at or near this stage five years ago. But a very lovely bottle, in any event.

Have you by chance opened a 2005 edition?
Sadly I missed getting Prum in 2005. There are very few '05s that aren't too sweet for me, but I'd imagine if anyone could get the balance right, it would be Prum.
 
I'll try to bring one if we have another jeeb at some point in the not-too-distant future.

Thanks, Jay. Hope all is well in the big apple.
 
originally posted by Ian Fitzsimmons:
I'll try to bring one if we have another jeeb at some point in the not-too-distant future.

Thanks, Jay. Hope all is well in the big apple.

Speaking of apples a few weeks ago I drove up to Rockland County to visit the cemetery and meet my brother for an outdoors lunch. Afterwards we went to the Orchards of Conklin, a local orchard that I hadn't been to in about 40 years. They no longer had the huge wooden casks of apple cider from which you could use a spigot to get a cup of cider or refill a container but I bought some apples and some cider.

The cider tasted the way I remembered cider tasting and how no cider in the last 40 years has managed to live up to. It was another wonderful Proustian moment.
 
Back
Top