winereactionsarethenewtrend

Mark Anisman

Mark Anisman
16 out this month
0 in
some company calling themselves Chamber Street Wines sent me some wine but I assume it was their mistake.

3 November : 2010 Domaine Huet Vouvray Demi-Sec Clos du Bourg
fresh. pear plum. great balance. super winner.
5 November : 2005 Domaine Denis Bachelet Gevrey-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes
burly. dense. soft (Bachelet). a little tannin initially but not noticed while eating the ******* *******. initial oak but not afterwards.cherry? not yet a 2005 fan as wines have been so muscular and i skew towards finesse . I wonder if this will ever perceptibly change but at least this is a wine that still has time on its’ side..
7 November : 2010 Domaine Dupasquier Mondeuse Vin de Savoie
feeling blue today, and joyously not seeing red. low alcohol mountain wine. black fruit asserts itself. délicieux. a wine for the people. tré scrantonesque. paired with meat.
10 November : 2012 Schloss Gobelsburg Riesling Reserve Gaisberg
i really like Austria 2012, at least from the wineries i purchased. very very good. hits the spot. balanced (that’s the key) and less power than in the “top" vintages. might not win contests but it triple doubles at the table. paired with food.
11 November : 2007 François Pinon Vouvray Silex Noir
good but simple as it lacked tension. would not walk away from the table though. paired with **** ***** quite nicely
12 November : 2001 Giacomo Conterno Barolo Cascina Francia
enjoyable and certainly youthful. i have always thought most classically made Barolo benefits from being older than 20 years old (if not 25). not the paragon of Barolo as led to expect from this producer, but perhaps more years will rectify the situation. paired with pasta
15 November : 2006 Simon Bize Savigny-lès-Beaune 1er Cru Les Fournaux
no. no. not again! a reprise from October. earthy with nicely delineated fruit. my cheating October impression :“sweet but hard / lean. all about rustic fruit, not complex per se. very Savigny.” very good burgundy. vegetables added at a last moment of inspiration to fill out the main course
17 November : 2009 Domaine de l'Ecu Muscadet de Sèvre-et-Maine Expression de Granit
lemony and a touch more body than expected for Muscadet but sensationally well balanced with the minerals and acidity. right up there with Pépière and L-P and Brégeon and Louvetrie and did i leave anyone out? paired with fish
19 November : 2017 La Graine Sauvage Vermentino
not your typical vermentino (small sample size admittedly). opulent style with nuttiness i seem to recall. the typical fruit and minerality present and accounted for, albeit shy. enjoyed as a change of pace. but it is all about expectations and i would not employ it at table when wanting the typical lean texture. paired with fish. perhaps i need to get out more often re : vermentino
19 November : 2010 Emidio Pepe Trebbiano d’Abruzzo
whoa doggies! this be super bad in a bad way!! sour and fizzy but in the something has gone wrong microbiologically way and not just some extra CO2. hope there is a good bottle out there for someone to enjoy. paired with backyard compost heap
21 November : 2001 Joh. Jos. Christoffel Erben Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Auslese
lacks the cut that keys the greatness of 2001 Christoffel wines. worst of any 2001 jjc i have had, yet still better than the majority of any German wine we have consumed!. we should all be so unlucky.. not scintillating but darn good. great fruit well defined as per usual. paired with Asian food
22 November : 2012 Weingut Knoll Riesling Smaragd Ried Schütt
not a precious / prestigious / esteemed vintage but oh so good. smaragd light if you will. all in balance and a wonderful wine
24 November : 2009 Pierre Gonon St. Joseph
fine effort. upfront syrah fruit and minimal intrusion of tannins. not my fave Gonon but see Christoffel. happiness to drink. would pay easily $733 for a bottle. paired with meat
26 November : 1996 Bruno Giacosa Barolo Falletto di Serralunga d’Alba
surprised initially by a somewhat short finish and a mildly weak mid palate concentration. filled out as the meal progressed to a very elegant and dang fine wine, just not as beautiful as other Giacosa wines i have drunk. paired with flour (i always get dried flour in the nebbiolo nose). Slow o’d for 4 minutes. Worried that was too long. Fortunately no harm done
28 November : 2013 Heidi Schröck Furmint
fresh with acidity. pear / savory / mineral. medium body. my neighbor chimed in with her favorable review of “fresh and crisp”. enjoyed and will buy more. i realize this is a boring pairing, but we opted for a reprise of food.
29 November : 2007 Domaine Marquis d'Angerville Volnay 1er Cru Champans
plump red fruit. beet root and alcohol barely sticks thru. no tannins to speak of. a replay of the 2009 Gonon characteristics. reasonable acidity so not too soft structurally. paired with muscle subjected to a heat treatment. a pleasure. so far, for the Volnay category Alex, i prefer 2007 Burgundy to 1999 Burgundy. 2007 revels in its’ simplicity and unabashedly crosses the street (not a walk of shame), where 1999 is more pedestrian and sticks to the sidewalk. your pedometer may vary.
 
Fun. Mostly good bottles so yay you. Re the Giacosa, I'd guess that more time in the decanter (like, 8 hrs) may have helped. I'll have to think about the qualities of Scranton that manifest in Vin Savoie.
 
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:
I'll have to think about the qualities of Scranton that manifest in Vin Savoie.
That one stumped me too. Are there other wines that are more Lancastrian or Bethlemesque?
Ah, I've got it: he smells banana esters in the wine.
 
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:
originally posted by Christian Miller (CMM):
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:
I'll have to think about the qualities of Scranton that manifest in Vin Savoie.
That one stumped me too. Are there other wines that are more Lancastrian or Bethlemesque?
Ah, I've got it: he smells banana esters in the wine.

It's easy to smell 30,000 pounds of bananas.
 
Scranton is the ancestral home of Biden. 7 November was the day where one felt in your bones that Biden was really to be president elect.
more later
thank you for reading. it can be a slog!

tré scrantonesque is equivalent to writing tré bidenesque...
i also put this note on another board and worried it would be cast out for political content. so i was definitely inscruting
 
originally posted by Mark Anisman:
7 November : 2010 Domaine Dupasquier Mondeuse Vin de Savoie
feeling blue today, and joyously not seeing red. low alcohol mountain wine. black fruit asserts itself. délicieux. a wine for the people. tré scrantonesque. paired with meat.

What has always been funny and mysterious to me is how many people I've met out in the wild that hailed from Scranton. Not my generation, but my parents. I guess everyone who could just left.

I have some vague but happy memories of some older Dupasquier with Guilhaume and others back in the old days when he still lived in SF. I remember liking them more than he did, which was a surprise. I'm not sure Mondeuse really develops in interesting ways, but my recollection is that the wines held up and lost a bit of structure.

originally posted by Mark Anisman:
12 November : 2001 Giacomo Conterno Barolo Cascina Francia
enjoyable and certainly youthful. i have always thought most classically made Barolo benefits from being older than 20 years old (if not 25). not the paragon of Barolo as led to expect from this producer, but perhaps more years will rectify the situation. paired with pasta

Yours is not the first or only report of issues with this wine. I do wonder if the heat of 2003 played a part in that cellars may not have been able to keep a good temperature. A recent 1998 was really good and that is another inconsistent vintage (although all of my bottles have been good or better).

originally posted by Mark Anisman:
19 November : 2010 Emidio Pepe Trebbiano d’Abruzzo
whoa doggies! this be super bad in a bad way!! sour and fizzy but in the something has gone wrong microbiologically way and not just some extra CO2. hope there is a good bottle out there for someone to enjoy. paired with backyard compost heap

Like Jeff's Simone, I seem to have pretty spotty experiences with these wines but when they're good, they're very good.

originally posted by Mark Anisman:
22 November : 2012 Weingut Knoll Riesling Smaragd Ried Schütt
not a precious / prestigious / esteemed vintage but oh so good. smaragd light if you will. all in balance and a wonderful wine

I wish I had some 2012s. A couple of recent 2015s have left a bit to be desired.

originally posted by Mark Anisman:
26 November : 1996 Bruno Giacosa Barolo Falletto di Serralunga d’Alba
surprised initially by a somewhat short finish and a mildly weak mid palate concentration. filled out as the meal progressed to a very elegant and dang fine wine, just not as beautiful as other Giacosa wines i have drunk. paired with flour (i always get dried flour in the nebbiolo nose). Slow o’d for 4 minutes. Worried that was too long. Fortunately no harm done

I have a couple of bottles left but all of my previous experiences have been good. In fact, this wine has always shown well for me, even when very young. I'll have to pull one of my remaining bottles and check it out.

Thanks for the interesting notes.
 
originally posted by VLM:

originally posted by Mark Anisman:
22 November : 2012 Weingut Knoll Riesling Smaragd Ried Schütt
not a precious / prestigious / esteemed vintage but oh so good. smaragd light if you will. all in balance and a wonderful wine

I wish I had some 2012s. A couple of recent 2015s have left a bit to be desired.

Are you referring to 2015 of that particular Knoll or Wachau/Austria more broadly? I know the vintage has a character that is not always the most digestible, but for Thanksgiving dinner I opened 2015 Alzinger Mühlpoint GV Smaragd and it was very desirable! Yes the middle palate fruit was sweetish but plenty of elegance and freshness.

Although, I suppose holding up Alzinger as an example of a fresh delicious wine is probably not fair!
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:
originally posted by VLM:

originally posted by Mark Anisman:
22 November : 2012 Weingut Knoll Riesling Smaragd Ried Schütt
not a precious / prestigious / esteemed vintage but oh so good. smaragd light if you will. all in balance and a wonderful wine

I wish I had some 2012s. A couple of recent 2015s have left a bit to be desired.

Are you referring to 2015 of that particular Knoll or Wachau/Austria more broadly? I know the vintage has a character that is not always the most digestible, but for Thanksgiving dinner I opened 2015 Alzinger Mühlpoint GV Smaragd and it was very desirable! Yes the middle palate fruit was sweetish but plenty of elegance and freshness.

Although, I suppose holding up Alzinger as an example of a fresh delicious wine is probably not fair!

We opened up a 2015 Knoll Gruner Smaragd Schutt with Thanksgiving and it was loose and a bit warm. I could have handled it if it were rich (I had planned on that) but it didn't have the density I was hoping for. That being said, my taste was off from intubation during surgery on Tuesday* and am now just getting back to normal taste-wise. That being said, I also had a Riesling Smaragd Kellerberg that was disappointing in the same way. I guess 2015 was solar and warm in a way that 1997 wasn't.

* I'm fine, it was routine surgery to take care of a hernia (although, routine surgery is only routine for the surgeon, for the patient recovery is still a bummer).
 
thank you all for the comments

yes indeed Jeff, perhaps not a stunning wine present but a super majority of complete satisfaction

Giacosa was a riddle. a small aliquot of a remainder 3 days down the road spoke to being a more complete wine. perhaps my high expectations and really wanting to like this wine smudged the truth of the wine and i missed it. will open a bottle in 2-3 years and see if it speaks truth to power. or merely truth to getting drunk.
so don't pull your last bottle out yet. my relative lack of enthusiasm may be operator dependent, both in my not decanting / airing out the wine or just opening the bottle before its' apogee has been reached.i did like it, just not as much as i thought i would. maybe next time i will not watch the PBS newshour before dinner.

i agree that the major shift of the Dupasquier mondeuse over time is structural. I have limited experience with other producers but i do have a Belluard and Péron for future experiments. I visited Domaine Prieuré Saint Christophe in 2008 and was gifted a bottle of 2003. that i will share with my friend i visited the winery with once viral loads diminish. that tasting was quite fun and his taciturn demeanor melted away when we thanked him for his time with a jug of maple syrup. i still can see his wide open smile as he then led us to his schatzkammer
 
originally posted by VLM:

We opened up a 2015 Knoll Gruner Smaragd Schutt with Thanksgiving and it was loose and a bit warm. I could have handled it if it were rich (I had planned on that) but it didn't have the density I was hoping for. That being said, my taste was off from intubation during surgery on Tuesday and am now just getting back to normal taste-wise....

Glad that you are on the mend. Diminished faculties is always a tough thing.

And yes, I'm no expert in 2015 Wachau, but from the regions I know better it is not my favorite vintage expression, despite being able to find plenty of delicious wines.
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:


And yes, I'm no expert in 2015 Wachau, but from the regions I know better it is not my favorite vintage expression, despite being able to find plenty of delicious wines.

Although German rieslings might be one standout of the vintage for me.
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:
originally posted by Rahsaan:


And yes, I'm no expert in 2015 Wachau, but from the regions I know better it is not my favorite vintage expression, despite being able to find plenty of delicious wines.

Although German rieslings might be one standout of the vintage for me.

I've found that good producers made good wines in the vintage, although a lot of that is based on red wines more than whites.
 
originally posted by VLM:
originally posted by Mark Anisman:
7 November : 2010 Domaine Dupasquier Mondeuse Vin de Savoie
feeling blue today, and joyously not seeing red. low alcohol mountain wine. black fruit asserts itself. délicieux. a wine for the people. tré scrantonesque. paired with meat.

What has always been funny and mysterious to me is how many people I've met out in the wild that hailed from Scranton. Not my generation, but my parents. I guess everyone who could just left.

My nephew moved to Scranton a few years ago. Apparently there's a growing Hasidic community there.
 
VLM, I read diminished faculties and intubation and panicked, jumping to the wrong but obvious conclusion. Regardless, hope that you’re feeling better now.

Mark Lipton
(Hunkered down for the post-T-day surge hereabouts)
 
originally posted by MLipton:
VLM, I read diminished faculties and intubation and panicked, jumping to the wrong but obvious conclusion. Regardless, hope that you’re feeling better now.

Mark Lipton
(Hunkered down for the post-T-day surge hereabouts)

Sorry, didn't mean to worry you. It was laparoscopic surgery with full anesthesia; hence, the intubation. Routine hernia surgery that had been delayed due to the pandemic. COVID-19 negative before and after. Hospitals, especially ones like Duke, are safer than grocery stores these days.

Yes, please hunker down. The midwest is a shitshow but vaccines are on the way (and isn't the mRNA platform just remarkable? I wish Joe were alive to see that).
 
originally posted by Mark Anisman:
so don't pull your last bottle out yet. my relative lack of enthusiasm may be operator dependent, both in my not decanting / airing out the wine or just opening the bottle before its' apogee has been reached.i did like it, just not as much as i thought i would. maybe next time i will not watch the PBS newshour before dinner.
I have one each of Villero and Rabaja left.

And, indeed, news from almost any source is incompatible with good ingestion. May I recommend something from the "Ambient" channel?

i agree that the major shift of the Dupasquier mondeuse over time is structural. I have limited experience with other producers but i do have a Belluard and Péron for future experiments. I visited Domaine Prieuré Saint Christophe in 2008 and was gifted a bottle of 2003. that i will share with my friend i visited the winery with once viral loads diminish. that tasting was quite fun and his taciturn demeanor melted away when we thanked him for his time with a jug of maple syrup. i still can see his wide open smile as he then led us to his schatzkammer
I have one bottle of Peillot 2008 Mondeuse waiting around for just such an experiment. If I recall my conversation with him correctly, he has back vintages going into his father's time but he thinks only a few of them have aged into something exciting.

ETA: I meant to praise your idea to gift maple syrup. Great idea.

originally posted by Jay Miller:
My nephew moved to Scranton a few years ago. Apparently there's a growing Hasidic community there.
Can they spray for that? Never mind.
 
I went in for all the Dupasquier when SM had the email list.

I've had some smoking bottles of the Deuse over the years - 02 and 10 have been standouts for me.

OTOH, an 05 at Thanksgiving was vegetal / green and much more agreeable to the corpulent washbasin.

I've sat on the pinot and gamay longer than I should have - I'm trying to remedy that right now (not right, right now, but soon).

What I miss is the Jacquere and rose.

I've never been able to get into the Marestel - if there are any fans out there, I would be glad to hook you up.
 
Best Mondeuse I've ever had was from Michel Grisard. I don't think much gets imported though. I'm lucky to have a good friend from Grenoble who brings it back to stateside after he visits his family.
 
Back
Top