Chris Coad
Chris Coad
He came from the planet of soy....
I won't forgive you!
Destroy all foreign sauces!
We're feeling better now, aren't we?
I won't forgive you!
Destroy all foreign sauces!
We're feeling better now, aren't we?
originally posted by SFJoe:
My comments were intemperate. I regret the tone.
Joe, go find a bottle of the '07 and report back. I found it a haunting, thrilling wine, easily holding its own in some very serious company ('93 Roumier Bonnes Mares could make many reds shrink in shame). Really, one of the best things I've had in ages. So I rose too vigorously to its defense.
originally posted by Florida Jim:
The 2006 is fabulous.
Best, Jim
Didn't Callahan and Stuart have a similar conversation about Overnoy Poulsard many moons ago?
Like politics, religion and The Great Pumpkin.originally posted by Chris Coad:
Didn't Callahan and Stuart have a similar conversation about Overnoy Poulsard many moons ago?
Yes, and "conversation" is being kind. This is a perilously polarizing wine. Perhaps it ought to come with a warning sticker: DRINK, BUT DO NOT DISCUSS.
originally posted by Marc D:
You two are re living historyDidn't Callahan and Stuart have a similar conversation about Overnoy Poulsard many moons ago?
I'm sure the page was Albanized, but something along the lines of a sweaty shepherdess exploding vs Overnoy being a swell guy and making authentic wine... blah, blah etc.
And you are getting the '07 already, huh. I just tried the 2006 which was very clean and not sweaty or dirty at all.
originally posted by Joe Dressner:
originally posted by Marc D:
You two are re living historyDidn't Callahan and Stuart have a similar conversation about Overnoy Poulsard many moons ago?
I'm sure the page was Albanized, but something along the lines of a sweaty shepherdess exploding vs Overnoy being a swell guy and making authentic wine... blah, blah etc.
And you are getting the '07 already, huh. I just tried the 2006 which was very clean and not sweaty or dirty at all.
The dispute was over the 1993. It had quite a stench but was loved by Callahan and Connell. I had mixed feelings about the wine. It suffered from insane over-reduction and no doubt has lively yeasts and bacteria.
None of the vintages we brought in since than have had that problem.
originally posted by VLM:
Both dog hind parts and doghead are adrift in the world, yet I remain.
I consumed a decent number of bottles of said wine and, with enough air, enjoyed most of them.
I like the Amanita muscaria rif.originally posted by Chris Coad: badgers
originally posted by Chris Coad:
Didn't Callahan and Stuart have a similar conversation about Overnoy Poulsard many moons ago?
Yes, and "conversation" is being kind. This is a perilously polarizing wine. Perhaps it ought to come with a warning sticker: DRINK, BUT DO NOT DISCUSS.
originally posted by SFJoe:
I like the Amanita muscaria rif.originally posted by Chris Coad: badgers
Though they don't explore the full spiritual implications of that fungus.
originally posted by Joel Stewart:
btw, not all species of amanita are created equal - "This genus is responsible for approximately 95% of the fatalities resulting from mushroom poisoning, with the death cap accounting for about 50% on its own."