Interesting- thanks, all.
My experience draws a bit from everyone's- at the table I preferred the non-Riesling offerings (though a '04 Kappelweg wasn't bad). The standouts were an '05 Auxerrois Moenchreben, an '04 Pinot Gris, and a '98 Gewurtz Obere Weingarten. I've got a question mark next to the price they were asking, and a scrawl on the younger Gewurtz asking where the palate was (though it was an '03, so I didn't hold it too much against it).
My experience draws a bit from everyone's- at the table I preferred the non-Riesling offerings (though a '04 Kappelweg wasn't bad). The standouts were an '05 Auxerrois Moenchreben, an '04 Pinot Gris, and a '98 Gewurtz Obere Weingarten. I've got a question mark next to the price they were asking, and a scrawl on the younger Gewurtz asking where the palate was (though it was an '03, so I didn't hold it too much against it).