I don't recognize this wine. Can you perhaps help some of us by giving a little bit more precision?originally posted by lucertoran:
Ch.Mu Grand Cru.
originally posted by lucertoran:
my bad G.Ch Grand Cru & Ch.Mu 1er Cru.
I always s#*%$ my P$#%6 when it comes to writing in english.originally posted by Joe Dressner:
Dear lucertoran:
Having trouble typing tonight?
Neither one.originally posted by Sharon Bowman:
And the Gevrey was a village or a 1er cru?
originally posted by lucertoran:
some Pacalet's 06G.Ch 1er Cru . austere as G.Ch( with more emphasis on structure than on aromatics) and a bit weak on the verge of oxydation(so young though!!!).
Ch.Mu Grand Cru. Texture & fruit: brilliant.Nice polished tannins.Ch.Mu being my favorite expression of PN .
What do you think camarades disorderist????
Nope. Up through 2008, it's just been the Charmes-Chambertin and Ruchottes-Chambertin for grand cru, but he has Chambertin-Clos-de-Bze and Echzeaux for 2009.originally posted by lucertoran:
I don t even think Pacalet is making Musigny & Bonnes Mares Grand cru.originally posted by Sharon Bowman:
And the Gevrey was a village or a 1er cru?
Well Charmes Chambertin is not a grand cru wthin the G.Ch appellation?originally posted by Sharon Bowman:
That's what I heard. Sounds exciting. But didn't he lose something, too? What was it, again?
My niggling with lucertoran was over the use of the expression "Gevrey-Chambertin Grand Cru," which obviously has no sense known to man.
Nor woman.
originally posted by lars makie:
Can we get Jay in here?To decipher this thread? And maybe Carson to explain Guilhaume's reply?
originally posted by lucertoran:
my bad G.Ch Grand Cru & Ch.Mu 1er Cru.
GTRDAFQDSLNTLJ!!!!!!originally posted by guilhaume:
originally posted by lucertoran:
some Pacalet's 06G.Ch 1er Cru . austere as G.Ch( with more emphasis on structure than on aromatics) and a bit weak on the verge of oxydation(so young though!!!).
Ch.Mu Grand Cru. Texture & fruit: brilliant.Nice polished tannins.Ch.Mu being my favorite expression of PN .
What do you think camarades disorderist????
AAMOF, IDK WAYTA,IDU
It is complicated. Charmes-Chambertin is physically within the Gevrey-Chambertin appellation and it can be declassified to appellation Gevrey-Chambertin 1er Cru or Gevrey Chambertin (or Bourgogne or vdt), but a grand cru is its own appellation apart from and different from the village appellation, and in fact, in the case of several grands crus (Bonnes-Mares, Montrachet, Btard-Montrachet; Corton and Corton-Charlemagne, too, but there are further complications with them that I won't get into) they are located in more than one village.originally posted by lucertoran:
Well Charmes Chambertin is not a grand cru wthin the G.Ch appellation?originally posted by Sharon Bowman:
That's what I heard. Sounds exciting. But didn't he lose something, too? What was it, again?
My niggling with lucertoran was over the use of the expression "Gevrey-Chambertin Grand Cru," which obviously has no sense known to man.
Nor woman.
originally posted by lucertoran:
GTRDAFQDSLNTLJ!!!!!!originally posted by guilhaume:
originally posted by lucertoran:
some Pacalet's 06G.Ch 1er Cru . austere as G.Ch( with more emphasis on structure than on aromatics) and a bit weak on the verge of oxydation(so young though!!!).
Ch.Mu Grand Cru. Texture & fruit: brilliant.Nice polished tannins.Ch.Mu being my favorite expression of PN .
What do you think camarades disorderist????
AAMOF, IDK WAYTA,IDU