2005 La Grapperie Lenchanteresse

Cory Cartwright

Cory Cartwright
2005 La Grapperie Lenchanteresse. A Garagiste semi-blind purchase. Apparently there is a market for this wine because I bought two bottles, but lord I wish I hadnt. I also wish I could say this wine was somehow flawed, but the four of us (guilhaume, Jim Hanlon, Emily, and myself) couldnt find any fault besides this just being plain bad. Descriptors ranged from rotting driftwood to old pickles. Jim said the horrble dill pickle flavor was probably due to full cluster fermentation with badly underripe stems. Whatever it was, it was not good. To top it off it was way too heavy (14%) which gave weight to all the problems. Really fucked wine.
 
A Garagiste semi-blind purchase...

Does anything ever good come from this formula?

I don't shop there myself, but I sure hear about all the woes of the patrons online. Of course there are selection effects at work. But still. Don't you have better shops nearby?
 
originally posted by Rahsaan:
A Garagiste semi-blind purchase...

Does anything ever good come from this formula?

I don't shop there myself, but I sure hear about all the woes of the patrons online. Of course there are selection effects at work. But still. Don't you have better shops nearby?

It is certainly popular sport to trash Rimmerman's business but I must say I've have had more hits than misses. And as I am local to Seattle I appreciate his bringing things into the state that other distributors wouldn't take chances on.

That being said I tried, last week, the Adonis (I think) from La Grapparie (also bought through Garagiste) and it was pure wretchedness. Like you said, not flawed, just nasty. Tasted like burdock root run through a juicer and fermented... unfortunately literally. It laughed off my patience at hoping it would become drinkable for three days before succumbing to the drain. I think it may have even got his *important* tag...?!
 
Enchanted

Dear Friends,

If you are into Frank Cornelissen, Cedric Bouchard, Francois Blanchard or any of our other pioneers, this offer is for you.

As far as the Loire and all things underground are concerned, Renaud Guettier of La Grapperie is playing with a stacked deck. He has produced a new super-cuvee based on the 2005 Adonis bottling especially for wine geeks (and extreme gastronomes) that will be discussed in more than a few circles. When I use the term super cuvee I do not mean more extract and alcohol, I mean even more eccentricity and magnetism. Instead of re-hashing the La Grapperie story, Ive reprinted my original offer for the La Grapperie Adonis below (which is sold out) to give you an idea of what were dealing with here. I would advise scrolling down, reading that first, and then coming back to this offer I will insert a pause here to allow you time to scroll down...

Now that youve read about the 2005 Adonis, todays offer is for the big sister, the Lenchanteresse. I tasted the 2005 Lenchanteresse for the first time yesterday and Im still thinking about it this afternoon it opened my mind the way Sgt. Pepper forced the cerebral cortex of the musical world to expand beyond its 1967 horizons. In a nutshell, for one winemaker to produce two red wines with this level of ingenuity and intrigue (the 2005 Adonis and 2005 Lenchanteresse - with Pineau dAunis no less) is not only revolutionary but needs to be proclaimed from the hilltops. Please allow me to nudge you with as much gentle force as I can.

While compatriots, the two wines have distinct differences. Where the Adonis is youthful, in-your-face and full of aromatic insanity, the Lenchanteresse is more regal, powerful and serious although its core is still centered around an aromatic free-for-all and the deep-toned, black colored, liquid cement and pepper-dusted palate that fans of the Adonis will relish. (A presence normally associated with Cabernet Franc - light-bodied Pineau dAunis this isnt). The grapes for the Lenchanteresse are hand-picked from the very oldest vines on the property (some are pre-phyloxera in a 1,9h parcel simply referred to as vignes centenaire and older) - they only produce a few bunches per plant. Instead of 12-15 months in 228L vessels (like the Adonis) the Lenchanteresse spends 24-30 months laying in wait all without any topping, additions, subtractions or added sulfur of any kind. The result is a production level that is almost too small to commercially offer (1160 bottles in 2005, approximately 96 cases) but I will take all that is presented (10-15 cases for the US - the rest is divvied up in 5 case lots for Germany, Switzerland and Belgium the remaining 40-50 cases for restaurants in France).

The 2005 Lenchanteresse is unlike anything else being produced in the Loire or in France it is almost an Ausone-like take on Chenin Noir with the Wizard of Oz character that La Grapperie has become synonymous with. It is a wine to study as much as it is to enjoy. As far as biodynamic and progressive entrants are concerned, La Grapperie is among the most cutting edge in France and I advise any bonafide wine pundit or blogger to be on the lookout for these wines before establishing a position of wholesale knowledge of the Loire. Not everyone will enjoy the wines of La Grapperie but they are a reference standard that needs to be tasted (at least once) to insure your palate is centered circa 2009 and not 2004 when Puzelats version of Pineau dAunis was the US reference. This is not a proclamation on the validity of Puzelat (most of you know I adore Thierrys wine) it is simply a statement from where I sit as of July 17th, 2009. In my mind, the world keeps moving forward and the quest for wine knowledge should continue to evolve with it.

With that said, La Grapperie is now among the most influential and intriguing French underground experiments of the moment all of the wines are well worth your experience and experimentation and they are far more enjoyable to actually drink than many of the pioneer wines we offer (unlike most of the entrants from someone like Frank Cornelissen, you can actually drink Lenchanteresse and fall in love with it simply from a vinous perspective).
 
I've got a bit of stuff waiting to be shipped from Garagiste. Just from over the course of the last year. Since I have to have it shipped here, which I'm still not sure how I'm going to do that (changes to IL shipping laws and all), I try to be fairly judicious when it comes to their offerings. I try to read between the lines as best I can and go for the things that I know that I can't get in Chicago. Like the Cornelissen, Puzelat and Orchis Mascula wines. I will say that I got sucked into the hype with the recent Bourdy releases; which I'm a bit worried about after VLM and someone else's verbal lashing not long ago. We'll see. You win some you lose some.

The bit that would scare me off on the Grapperie offer above is the "Ausone-like take on Chenin Noir".
 
I have had one good bottle of Adonis 2005, at Terroir I believe. Or maybe not. Isn't it brought in by the little people?

This whole "French Underground" hipster bullshit is a distinct turn-off to me. I want geeky ass motherfuckers like Eric making my wines. It reminds me of the same shit with Helen Turley years back. If she had so much as farted at the winery in question it was used to shill the wine. Now it's Corneilsen or whomever. If it smells like shit, chances are that it is shit.

Lars, the Bourdy wines were terrible. I'm bummed for you.
 
I've had the Adonis twice and liked it both times, but that was before I realized it was a hipster wine. Thanks for pointing that out, I'll promise not to like the next bottle.

2005 La Grapperie Adonis: Purchased in Paris at the recommendation of Julian Aujeau who runs a terrific little wine shop in Le Marais. (Part of a mixed case he recommended--all winners and none over 25 euros). Light and almost transparent. Peaty nose with smoke and fresh red fruits. Nice minerality. Fresh long finish. I liked it better than the rest of the table, who were put off a bit by the funk/peat.

2005 La Grapperie Coteaux du Loir Adonis

11/16/2009 rated 90 points: Medium to light red, red/rose. Clear, but not bright. Tangy, zesty and savory. Agave predominates. Flavors are very well-delineated and quite distinct. Surprisingly, showing even better than a bottle drank in 2007. I wouldn't have guessed these would improve with time.
 
originally posted by James Sanders:
I've had the Adonis twice and liked it both times, but that was before I realized it was a hipster wine. Thanks for pointing that out, I'll promise not to like the next bottle.

Oh, you can like it I'm just over the marketing thing. I like plenty of wines that could be categorized as hipster.
 
I have had one amazing bottle of Adonis and one bad bottle. I drank the amazing bottle before the Garagiste email and now own six bottles of the L'enchanteresse. I will try my first one in Williamsburg and see if the whole hipster milieu will help.

Hipster.
 
originally posted by Cory Cartwright:
I've enjoyed both the Adonis and the Gravot in the past (and sold both of them). Neither is close to as bad as this wine.
Now, there's a great example of damnation with faint praise!
 
Hipster wine?
Produced in accordance with cutting edge dogmatic trends, sold on the desirability of its general unavailability, the challenge it presents tastewise and ones reaction to it, will then determine the true
nature or extent of ones hipster credentials. Is that how it works?

I confess to having succumbed to the allure of hipster cred on this. My hipster aspirations fortunately lack true commitment because I only sought a couple of bottles. I did however bring one to share with some
fellow disorderlies where it was roundly and deservedly disliked. Which is the rarely discussed dark
underbelly of hipster wine, when you show up with a wine bad enough that it makes you look like a jackass. Not that a true hipster would care.
 
originally posted by Ned Hoey:
Which is the rarely discussed dark
underbelly of hipster wine, when you show up with a wine bad enough that it makes you look like a jackass. Not that a true hipster would care.
Seriously. It's not as though you'd made the stuff. One has to have a little distance from bottles beyond one's control.
 
originally posted by Cory Cartwright:
I know the producer's other cuvees, but this one seems to stay in France. Seems like there's a reason for this.
Jean Pierre Robinot is Renaud's mentor.
If you know the wines from L'Ange Vin you will easily understand why the Grapperie's wines are like this.
Variation and supernaturalness are two terms you need to take in consideration when you drink these.
I have a lot of fun with these type of wines. I don t like the idea of perfection.
A "bad" bottle just encourage me to try again and again the fluid.It gives room for surprises as you open them again and again.
Damn that idea of Hipster shit.Certain people are just trying to make their stuff their own way.Most of those producers don t give a crap about being up high in the hipster spheres.
I have much respect for all these folks for being courageous and not taking in consideration the public's opinion.
La Grapperie is in activity since 04'....so we can give him some time to bring us more accomplished wines.
It seems that people on this board only drink high end stuff and and are easily prone to criticism.
We should all encourage him to pursue his work.
 
I know what you are saying luc, and you know I like Grapperie's other cuvees. They do exhibit a lot of bottle variation and stylistically they are very different from almost anything I've drank, save the Emile Heredia wines. That said the criticism is warranted, and the "idea of perfection" doesn't have anything to do with it. This was a thirty dollar bottle of shit wine that no one liked. Not Guilhaume, Jim, Emily or myself.
 
I know what you are saying luc, and you know I like Grapperie's other cuvees. They do exhibit a lot of bottle variation and stylistically they are very different from almost anything I've drank, save the Emile Heredia wines. That said the criticism is warranted, and the "idea of perfection" doesn't have anything to do with it. This was a thirty dollar bottle of shit wine that no one liked. Not Guilhaume, Jim, Emily or myself.
 
Back
Top