TN: Dinner at Ping's (Sept 29, 2013)

Jeff Grossman

Jeff Grossman
attendees: Jeff & Dena, Ross, Don, Jay, Brad, Jeff

We are deep in Chinatown. This time we are meeting Jeff & Dena at Ping's Seafood. Service is good although the only wow dish is the fried rice (which arrives inexplicably late, way after all the other food has been served, eaten, and the plates bussed). So it goes.

We had some wow wines, though:

Trimbach 2001 Riesling VT "Cuvee Frederic Emile" - great acidity, apricotty but really more complicated than that, very long finish, outstanding bottle

F. Chidaine 2009 Montlouis "Les Lys" - a somewhat rare bottling; delicate orange blossom and a hint of lychee, acidity is very soft, however

Huet 1996 Vouvray Sec "Le Mont" - a forceful wine but double-decanted 5 hours ahead so showing more gracefully, marzipan and yellow fruit, tangy and tight, do not open anytime soon

A. Foreau 1955 Vouvray Doux - so sweet! burned caramel and cork taint... damn

S. Magnien 2011 Morey-Saint-Denis 1er "Aux Petites Noix" - bright acidity but very shut down, just a hint of buttery oak showing (bleh)

Huet 1957 Vouvray Demi-Sec "Le Clos du Bourg" - not so sweet as the label might lead you to think, clear and crisp, subtle, others liked this more than me

O. Raffault 1979 Chinon - nice older franc still showing some pyrazines, good acidity (not high, not low), somewhere in the background there's leather and tobacco, a gentle drink

P. Foreau 1996 Vouvray Moelleux - Look! Young Loire wine! bright, yellow-fruited, sweet and easy, ahhh

Miller-Catoir 2001 Haardter Burgergarten Riesling Spatlese - 09 02, spritzy at age 12? suave, good acidity, a bit on the ripe side

J. J. Prum 1976 Wehlener Sonnenuhr Riesling Auslese Goldkapsel - 30 77; elixir, no words can do this justice, an example of why we buy wine

Dom. Baumard 1971 Quarts de Chaume - sweet, good, but lacks intensity, still not sure why Brad likes this house so much
 
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:
F. Chidaine 2009 Montlouis "Les Lys" - a somewhat rare bottling; delicate orange blossom and a hint of lychee, acidity is very soft, however

somewhat rare? Nah. 1990, 2003... am I missing one?

I love this wine.

A 2009 ripe Montlouis better have soft acidity next to a bunch of Huet and a Trimbach. Wait, didn't you also some German rieslings?

Huet 1996 Vouvray Sec "Le Mont" - a forceful wine but double-decanted 5 hours ahead so showing more gracefully, marzipan and yellow fruit, tangy and tight, do not open anytime soon

hey, did you have a blue cork as well?
I agree; it will be a while before I open another one.
 
originally posted by .sasha:
Huet 1996 Vouvray Sec "Le Mont" - a forceful wine but double-decanted 5 hours ahead so showing more gracefully, marzipan and yellow fruit, tangy and tight, do not open anytime soon
hey, did you have a blue cork as well?
I agree; it will be a while before I open another one.
Cork had about a half-inch of black mold at the top but was uniform (and solid) otherwise.
 
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:

Huet 1996 Vouvray Sec "Le Mont" - a forceful wine but double-decanted 5 hours ahead so showing more gracefully, marzipan and yellow fruit, tangy and tight, do not open anytime soon
I like that wine tight, I like that wine loose, I like that wine any which way.
 
originally posted by SFJoe:
originally posted by Jeff Grossman:

Huet 1996 Vouvray Sec "Le Mont" - a forceful wine but double-decanted 5 hours ahead so showing more gracefully, marzipan and yellow fruit, tangy and tight, do not open anytime soon
I like that wine tight, I like that wine loose, I like that wine any which way.

as long as it's pale
 
Fun night and It was great to see Jeff and Dena Morris again. No idea when I'll get notes up, but I'll try as I seem to disagree with Jeff a little more than usual. For instance, The '57 Huet was the best showing I've had and all my previous showings have been pretty damn good. This was a pretty magical bottle. The Muller-Catoir was also stellar and showing much fresher than a number of other bottles I've had. The '71 Baumard was also showing nicely. On the other hand, I don't believe I liked the '79 Olga Raffault or '96 Foreau as much as Jeff did. I also had the Chidaine when it was opened eight days previously this past Sunday, when Don originally brought it over to my place for Coad's birthday dinner. Still working on those notes, too. I saw Chris writing, so I'm hoping he'll get something up.
 
Back
Top